Why Emma Frost Fans Are Upset With X-Men ’97 Season 2’s Treatment of Her Character

X-Men ’97 Season 2 has earned strong reviews, but its second episode, A Force to Be Reckoned With, has ignited a backlash over one character. Emma Frost, the diamond-skinned telepath, resurfaced in the episode after surviving the Genosha genocide in Season 1. In the Season 2 episode, the X-Force seeks help from Emma, who is now a high-society matchmaker in London who brokers business deals.

The X-Force comes seeking intel on her client, Apocalypse, and she directs them to an abandoned base. However, it was a trap, as the government-backed mutant-hunting team X-Factor was lying in wait. It turns out Emma has been quietly collaborating with X-Factor, helping round up fellow mutants to secure her own amnesty.

X-Men ’97 Season 2	Details
Voice Cast	Ray Chase, Jennifer Hale, Alison Sealy-Smith, Cal Dodd, J. P. Karliak, Lenore Zann, George Buza, A. J. LoCascio, Holly Chou, Isaac Robinson-Smith, Matthew Waterson, Ross Marquand, Adrian Hough, Gates McFadden, John de Lancie, and Michael Dorn
Release Date	July 1, 2026
Episodes	9
RT Score (As of July 5, 2026)	100% | 91%
Streaming on	Disney+

As the two teams begin to fight, she turns to diamond and coolly inspects her nails. For longtime Emma Frost readers, this is a regression too far. They argue the show has trapped a character who long ago outgrew villainy back in her Hellfire Club villain era.

And worse, they felt that she would never become an active collaborator in mutant oppression. Fans believed Season 2 had done the character an injustice, even though it had earned glowing reviews, including from Callie Hanna of FW. Hanna praised “all the lovable characters, epic action, and shockingly deep emotions” in our review of X-Men ’97 Season 2. Here’s why Emma Frost fans felt different.

Emma Frost Was More Sympathetic in the Comics By This Point

Much of the fan frustration over X-Men ’97‘s Emma Frost characterization stems from the timeline. In Chris Claremont and John Byrne’s 1980 Dark Phoenix Saga, the character debuted as a genuine villain serving as the icy White Queen of the Hellfire Club. Throughout the ’80s, she ran a rival academy to Professor X’s, and led her students, the Hellions.

Beginning with 1994’s Generation X, Emma turned her talents toward teaching and protecting young mutants. In Grant Morrison’s New X-Men, she had become a full-fledged member and leader of the team. The change in her was brought by the Genosha genocide and the death of her Hellions.

By the point the show is depicting, comic Emma had been walking a heroic path for the better part of a decade. The show adapted stories built around a reformed Emma, but fans alleged that the show continued to carry on her villainy with the latest betrayal. Here is what upset fans had to say about this characterization.

Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost

However, other fans didn’t find any issue with Emma’s characterization. They believed that Emma’s villainy should be allowed to be shown in order for her redemption to make sense. They added that the show has never given us any reason for Emma to be heroic. Here are the arguments supporting the show’s take.

Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost

It is understandable why fans were upset with this characterization. Even her wealth and sensuality, once shorthand for villainy, were long ago reframed as tools she uses to empower mutants rather than betray them. However, there’s still time for the show to bring about her redemption arc.

Fans Believe Emma Frost Would Never Help to Imprison Mutants

Besides the objection over her villainy, some fans also noted how Emma Frost would never help round up innocent mutants, even in her villain era. Emma was a teacher who began a new school for mutants. So, her complicity in X-Factor’s roundup of mutants feels like a betrayal of her core.

That sting sharpens with the Stepford Cuckoos, who appear in the episode briefly, imprisoned in the helicarrier. In the comics, the Cuckoos are Emma’s cloned daughters. They are a set of identical young telepaths she mentors and fiercely protects. So, the notion of her helping imprison mutants like them rubs fans the wrong way. Here’s what one fan had to say about that.

Comment
by u/EJ_REDIT from discussion
in EmmaFrost

Moreover, in the comics, the Cuckoos lost two of their number over the course of the New X-Men storyline. The show features only three out of the five, hinting that the tragic events in Emma’s life may have already happened. It makes things even harder to square.

Do you think Emma Frost’s characterization was justified in the new season? Let us know in the comments below!

All three episodes of X-Men ’97 are now available for streaming on Disney+.