Opinion: A tax on public safety. Why the B.C. government must reverse its Oct. 1 PST expansion

On Oct. 1, the provincial sales tax will be applied to professional services, including the security we have had to rely on to keep our community safe, writes Nico Slobinsky. Photo by motimeiri /Getty Images

Article content

In May, I toured a Vancouver Jewish day school where one moment struck me: In the hallway between classes, we met the school’s therapy dogs.

Article content

These dogs weren’t just a nice addition, but a necessity to calm distressed children who didn’t understand why their school needed enhanced security and a regular police presence.

Article content

Article content

Imagine a child attending a Jewish school playing behind a high-security barrier, while children at the nearby public school enjoy recess without fear for their safety.

Article content

Article content

Yet, this has become a normalized experience for the Jewish community after the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist attacks.

Article content

Article content

According to a 2025 Jewish Federation of British Columbia survey, nearly two-thirds of community members experienced an antisemitic incident (62 per cent), and nine-in-10 (93 per cent) feel less secure.

Article content

While law enforcement has been a steadfast partner, the B.C. Jewish community has always had to bear some cost of keeping itself safe.

Article content

Before 2023, Jewish community organizations across Metro Vancouver spent less than $10,000 per month on security; three years later, we spend more than $200,000 per month.

Article content

Not only have our synagogues, Jewish schools and community centres been forced to enhance security, but so have our community housing, social service agencies, summer camps, and arts and culture festivals.

Article content

As we approach the Jewish High Holidays and the third year since the event that marked the beginning of this unprecedented wave of antisemitism, we are seeing a further cost increase coming.

Article content

On Oct. 1, the provincial sales tax (PST) will be applied to professional services, including the security we have had to rely on to keep our community safe.

Article content

Article content

That means our community organizations will have to pay at least another $168,000 annually to ensure families can send their children to school or daycare, seniors can access programming, community agencies can provide services to the vulnerable and worshippers can attend synagogue with some assurance.

Article content

Article content

Those are desperately needed funds that won’t go toward providing healthy meals at the Jewish Food Bank, keeping rents affordable at community housing sites, subsidizing a Jewish education for children from low-income families or helping seniors, including Holocaust survivors, live a dignified retirement.

Article content

These are hard choices that Jewish non-profits, charities and organizations in B.C. will feel acutely, but others will too.

Article content

Small businesses, already dealing with economic uncertainty, will have to pay extra to keep employees and customers safe.

Article content

Community and street festivals, often powered by volunteers and limited grant funding, will face challenges, including cancellations, as they celebrate local culture amid rising security costs after last year’s Lapu Lapu Day festival tragedy.