Vivian Bercovici: Benjamin Netanyahu will not go quietly after indecisive election

Article content

Article content

By Wednesday evening, the

Article content

Article content

is proving to be much more fluid with 53 seats for the right and 48 for change.

Article content

And the surprise wedge holding the balance of power? Two parties representing the Arab voters — 20 per cent of the Israeli population. They turned out to vote in

Article content

Article content

— 80 per cent  — and were

Article content

Article content

to do so in large part due to what they consider to be the racist tendencies of Netanyahu’s Minister of National Security, Itamar Ben Gvir.

Article content

He controlled the Israeli police force and transformed it into an institution that many believe has been soft on a wave of Jewish terrorism in the West Bank, and done nothing to address an alarming crime wave in Israeli Arab cities and towns. The irony of the Arab vote holding the balance of power in this country is not lost on anyone. Nor was the need for disjunctive comic relief.

Article content

Just a half hour after the polls closed at 10 p.m. Tuesday and early results were being reported, Israel’s most-watched television station — channel 12 — pivoted to

Article content

Eretz Nehederet

Article content

(“My Beautiful Country”). The show is Israel’s Saturday Night Live and it is masterful. For 25 minutes or so they delivered hilarious parodies on the various party leaders and possible outcomes, giving us all a much-needed laugh. At one point in the sketch, the actor playing hardliner Avigdor Lieberman, who insists that he will never sit with a coalition that includes Arab or ultra-orthodox parties, is cuddling up to Mansour Abbas, leader of the Arab Ra’am party.

Article content

Article content

Lieberman is perceived to be ideologically resolute, while

Article content

Article content

is generally regarded as being a pragmatic politician who will consider supporting either bloc, with the right terms, of course. In fact, following the closing of the polls, Abbas disclosed that both the Netanyahu and Eisenkot camps had been in contact with him regarding the upcoming negotiations.

Article content

The Arab Joint List — an amalgam of several small parties, is projected to win 12 seats. Together, with Abbas’ Ra’am party, Israeli Arabs may soon command 19 seats, an unprecedented game-changer. Due to their make-up of communists and overtly anti-Zionist interests they are a far less palatable option for any coalition to include.

Article content

Add to all of the above the fact that there are 650,000 uncounted votes,

Article content

Article content

Included in this

Article content

Article content

are diplomats, soldiers and reservists, Israelis displaced domestically by October 7 and ensuing conflict, election workers (an astonishing 100,000), police officers, prison employees and others.

Article content

What many are seeing in this murky outcome is a need for national unity. Finessing that is somewhat unfathomable, given the conflicting priorities and deep domestic schisms roiling Israel.

Article content

Article content

A coalition headed by Netanyahu and including change parties led by Eisenkot, former Prime Ministers Naftali Bennett and Ya’ir Lapid comes to 58. After that, it gets very tricky. Each of the smaller parties has set out intransigent conditions. Then again, Israeli politicians have been known to adapt key principles when in exchange for power. Meaning — that nothing should or can be ruled out.

Article content

Netanyahu is highly unlikely to submit to the leadership of another. He is already being

Article content

Article content

as “defiant”, in spite of the indecisive outcome.

Article content

Eisenkot is sticking to his assertion that Israel voted for change. Should Netanyahu resist relinquishing power, Eisenkot would demand significant concessions from the prime minister which he would be unlikely to accept.

Article content

The scenarios are endless. One example would have Netanyahu revive key elements of the highly controversial judicial reform that set off unprecedented domestic unrest before October 7. For the change bloc, they would have to negotiate some form of State Commission of Inquiry into October 7 that would be less comprehensive than what 71 per cent of Jewish Israelis (and 52 per cent of their Arab compatriots) demand.

Article content

Netanyahu is highly unlikely to submit to the authority of an inquiry that he does not control.

Article content

It is difficult to see a resounding mandate for anyone in this outcome. Everything will turn on the final tally and subsequent negotiations. Those are the only certainties.

Article content

Vivian Bercovici is a former Canadian ambassador to Israel.

Article content