‘It pays greater attention’: Steven Spielberg Can Stand Proud After What Hayao Miyazaki Thinks of His Studio When Pit Against Disney

When it comes to Japanese animation, few names command the same respect as universally as Hayao Miyazaki. The co-founder of Studio Ghibli has consistently delivered cinematic masterpieces that transcend the animation genre. However, what’s Miyazaki’s opinion on Western Animation giants such as Disney or DreamWorks? In answer, he illustrated the signature styles and strong suits of each of these studios.

Hayao Miyazaki’s Howl’s Moving Castle | Credit: Studio Ghibli

Steven Spielberg, while primarily known for live-action films, has left an indelible mark on animation through his involvement with DreamWorks; the studio he co-founded. In an interview, Miyazaki provided rare praise for DreamWorks; emphasizing the unique storytelling, character depth, and visually striking animation.

Hayao Miyazaki on Disney vs. DreamWorks

In an interview conducted by Xin Jin Bao in 2004, the legendary filmmaker, Hayao Miyazaki was asked about his view on Western animation studios such as Disney and DreamWorks. In answer, Miyazaki expressed his admiration for Disney’s earlier works, describing them as akin to classical ballet; timeless, elegant, and steeped in tradition.

On the contrary, Miyazaki stated that DreamWorks is quite the opposite of Disney in this term as he distinguished DreamWorks as being “anti-traditional”, likening their productions to modern pop music. This comparison highlights DreamWorks’ emphasis on innovation and reliability, as in Miyazaki’s words,

DreamWorks’ focus on character-driven plots and detailed storytelling resonates with Miyazaki’s philosophy. Unlike Disney, which often leans heavily on universal archetypes and traditional themes, DreamWorks has embraced a broader spectrum of stories, incorporating humor, cultural commentary, and complex character arcs.

The Prince of Egypt | Credit: DreamWorks Studio

One film that perfectly depicts DreamWorks’ distinct approach is The Prince of Egypt. Directed by Brenda Chapman, Steve Hickner, and Simon Wells, this 1998 masterpiece remains a shining example of DreamWorks’ ability to craft emotionally resonant stories. The film tells the story of Moses, blending breathtaking visuals with a powerful narrative steeped in historical and spiritual significance. Although somewhat underrated, its lasting appeal speaks to the studio’s ability to create profound and timeless works.

The role of traditional and national identity in animation

Hayao Miyazaki also highlighted the importance of cultural identity in animation through his comment, praising works from mainland China, Taiwan, and Korea for their unique aesthetics and deep ties to tradition. For instance, he mentioned a Hong Kong-based animated film named, Siu Sin AKA A Chinese Ghost Story, which depicts the aesthetics of Chinese tradition quite skillfully.

Siu Sin | Credit: Triangle Staff

Similarly, he praised Korean animation industry workers for their attention to detail, high sense of professionalism, and their own unique understanding of animation. According to Miyazaki, national and traditional elements make animation more charming and impactful. Needless to mention, his sentiments also echo the philosophy behind DreamWorks’ productions, which often incorporate diverse cultural elements.

In an ever-evolving medium, the mutual respect between legends like Miyazaki and other animation pioneers reminds us that animation is not bound by borders or conventions. Miyazaki’s acknowledgment of these efforts is a testament to the studio’s vision and commitment to innovation. By focusing on emotionally rich narratives, character complexity, and cultural authenticity, DreamWorks also has set itself as a revolutionary animation hub, and Steven Spielberg can stand proud of it.

Studio Ghibli and DreamWorks’ films are currently available to watch on Netflix.