Fake pollsters and bogus polls becoming a real issue in U.S. midterms

Sophisticated AI tools are making it difficult to identify phony pollsters and made-up data as the U.S. heads into midterm elections. Photo by Kamil Krzaczynski/AFP via Getty Images

Article content

A self-described U.S. polling firm whose data was tracked by political campaigns and mainstream media has admitted that its polls were fabricated, in the second such scandal to stir controversy ahead of the midterm elections.

Article content

The case involving the firm Wedgewood Polls threatens to erode trust in independent pollsters in an already hyperpolarized political climate, particularly as political pundits voice concern that fast-evolving AI tools are making it easier to fabricate results.

Article content

Article content

Article content

The case came to light earlier this week after polling aggregator FiftyPlusOne contacted Wedgewood as part of an investigation into the firm’s surveys.

Article content

Article content

Wedgewood responded with a statement on X admitting that “most” of its data had been made up.

Article content

It said the firm had been experimenting on how easy it could be for “an entirely fabricated polling firm to gain traction” and “be taken seriously.”

Article content

It turns out that Wedgewood, whose X account has since been taken down, was indeed taken seriously.

Article content

Michigan Senate candidate Mallory McMorrow said after the group’s “poll” in late June showed her support in the single digits, she said “donations dried up,” volunteers were “devastated,” and the media “hounded” her “with calls to drop out.”

Article content

“It killed us,” McMorrow wrote on X.

Article content

The bogus data, which covered high-profile races across several states, were also highlighted by major polling aggregators and news outlets, including The New York Times.

Article content

In an editors’ note, The Times said its poll tracker database included 15 surveys released by Wedgewood between June and October, all of which have now been removed.

Article content

Article content

Brendan Carr, chairman of the Federal Communications Commission, said there has been “a significant surge in entirely fake polls and suppression polls” designed to interfere with the electoral process.

Article content

Article content

He urged the media not to amplify such hoaxes and engage in “news distortions.”

Article content

In August, another phony group called Median Strategies admitted to fabricating poll results, saying it was “created as a short term social experiment,” according to the Los Angeles Times.

Article content

On Thursday, in a blog titled “more pollster funny business,” FiftyPlusOne said it will no longer collect polling data by another firm called SoCal Strategies, after an investigation that cast doubt on its authenticity.

Article content

The firm could not be reached for comment. SoCal Strategies’s website, X account, and Substack page appeared to have been taken offline.

Article content

The revelations comes amid warnings that AI-powered tools were enabling the fakery.

Article content

“It’s getting easier to conduct low-quality polls — or fake them altogether,” FiftyPlusOne said.

Article content

Sophisticated AI tools were also making it difficult to identify phony pollsters and made-up data, the American Association for Public Opinion Research said in a statement.