Scott Stinson: Ontario buys $28.9M private jet for Premier Doug Ford’s travel

The interior of a Bombardier Inc. Challenger 650 business jet is seen during the Singapore Airshow in 2018. Photo by SeongJoon Cho /Bloomberg

Article content

Maybe Premier Doug Ford was just trying to emphasize the importance of interprovincial trade in these difficult economic times.

Article content

The Ontario government has spent almost $30 million on a Quebec-made Bombardier Challenger 650 executive jet, to be used primarily for the premier’s travel. An official in Ford’s office told the Toronto Star, which first revealed the purchase on Friday morning, that the used, 10-year-old plane, could be used for other government purposes in emergencies, but that its main purpose is for Ford’s “extensive travel” within Canada and to the United States.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Provincial opposition leaders on Friday sounded like they couldn’t believe this bit of good fortune had dropped into their laps.

Article content

Article content

Outraged statements from both the NDP and Liberals landed in Queen’s Park press gallery inboxes within a minute of each other shortly after the purchase was revealed, each managing to use the nickname “Gravy Plane,” which will be impossible for the Progressive Conservative premier to shake.

Article content

“Families are struggling to buy groceries,” NDP Leader Marit Stiles lamented.

Article content

“People can’t afford groceries and gas, and Doug Ford is buying himself a private jet,” said John Fraser, interim leader of the Liberals. “That is tired and out of touch.”

Article content

The Liberals quickly arranged for Fraser to take questions from reporters, where he declared himself “gobsmacked” by the decision to buy a $28.9-million private jet amid an affordability crisis.

Article content

The opposition leaders have a point about the optics of the whole thing.

Article content

There might be a perfectly viable business case for the Ontario government to own and operate a private jet for the premier’s travel. The current practice of chartering private jets for certain travel would obviously be costly, and Ontario is a huge place. Ford has also been making a number of trips to the United States in recent months, drumming up support for increased state government and business ties to the province amid President Donald Trump’s ongoing trade war.

Article content

Article content

His office also pointed out that the Quebec and federal governments have recently made purchases of new Challenger jets, and in greater numbers, than Ontario’s single used plane.

Article content

Article content

It’s also true that a number of large, private companies own jets for executive use, on the justification that the speed and convenience of such travel, saving several hours per use relative to commercial flights, gives the executives more time to focus on their important jobs.

Article content

A Bombardier Inc. Challenger 650 business jet stands on display at the Singapore Airshow. Photo by SeongJoon Cho /Bloomberg

Article content

Do we really expect the premier of Ontario to, as the NDP’s Stiles said on Friday, “fly economy like the rest of us?”

Article content

I’m not convinced that having Ford take a premium economy flight to somewhere in the States, boarding in Zone 7, is necessarily the best use of his time.

Article content

(Fraser said that former premier Dalton McGuinty routinely flew commercial when returning to his Ottawa riding, although there’s an argument to be made that kind of travel would be less about official government business and more his duties as an MPP.)

Article content

Sometimes governments have to make expensive purchases because that is the nature of the job, even if it might make the tax-paying public wince at the price tag. This is how the official residence at 24 Sussex has effectively been left uninhabitable after needed repairs have been put off for years — because no one wants to deal with the fallout from headlines that would express shock at how much the prime minister was spending on sprucing up his digs. Even Justin Trudeau, master of the poorly thought out photo op, sniffed out the dodgy optics on that one.