Governments get marks for prioritizing provincial trade barriers, but must ‘step up’ on results: CFIB

The federal government has authority over interprovincial trade but has never been willing to use its leverage to bring down interprovincial trade barriers. Photo by Steph Crosier/Kingston Whig-Standard/Postmedia

Article content

A leading business group is giving some provinces and the federal government good grades for trying to break down Canada’s costly internal trade obstacles, even as those barriers continue to cost Canadians billions of dollars a year.

Article content

In its annual report on internal trade due to be released Wednesday, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) credited Ottawa and the provinces for their efforts in trying to tackle internal trade barriers, while acknowledging that most of the “significant progress” stems from the increased attention they’re paying to the problem, without much by way of results.

Article content

Article content

Article content

The federal government, which removed all federal barriers to internal trade a year ago, was given an A+ grade after receiving a mark of C a year earlier. Eight of the 10 provinces received As this year, with British Columbia receiving an A-. Newfoundland and Labrador didn’t receive a grade because of a recent government change.

Article content

Article content

The grades were much higher than in most years, the report said, because of a new multiplier that kicked in a year ago for those provinces that changed their rules to recognize some of the regulations and standards of other jurisdictions.

Article content

But Keyli Loeppky, one of the authors of the report, The State of Internal Trade, said governments should expect harsher grading next year because CFIB will be looking for tangible results. Loeppky, CFIB’s senior director for Alberta and interprovincial affairs, also said that the group wants to see the federal government start to use its ability to penalize and reward provinces for working to tear down trade walls.

Article content

Loeppky said Ottawa may have to get tougher because it’s unlikely the provinces will get very far on their own.

Article content

Article content

“They do need to step up,” said Loeppky. “We’ve seen enough announcements — now we want to see results.”

Article content

Article content

The federal government has authority over interprovincial trade but has never been willing to use its leverage — perhaps including adjusting big-ticket transfer payments or corporate subsidies — to bring down interprovincial trade barriers.

Article content

Despite the good grades, many economists, businesses and even governments say that more needs to be done to remove barriers, and faster.

Article content

Intergovernmental Affairs Minister Dominic LeBlanc met a couple of weeks ago with his provincial and territorial counterparts and later released a statement that emphasized the need to uphold previous commitments that have largely not been met.

Article content

Most businesses, meanwhile, aren’t yet seeing clearer trade paths across the country, nor are workers in a range of professions finding it easier to move from one province to the next because of unharmonized accreditation standards. According to the report, a clear majority of Canadian small businesses (70 per cent) have not noticed a change in the ease of doing business across provincial borders.