Colby Cosh: David Eby’s election call is perfectly legitimate

BC NDP leader and Premier David Eby crosses a fence following an election speech focused on healthcare at Peace Arch Provincial Park in Surrey, BC Wednesday, September 23, 2026. Photo by Jason Payne/ PNG

Article content

I’m not an expert on British Columbia. The map of B.C. in my imagination is not strong on detail; it could best be described as medieval, perhaps Tolkienesque. There are cute little drawings in appropriate places of street junkies, and Chinese dumplings, and retired Alberta truck dealers on skis. But I can summarize my views on Premier David Eby’s snap election call in British Columbia easily.

Article content

Article content

Which is to say: I almost literally couldn’t believe he would go through with it. Last Tuesday I was careful, to the point of being slightly frantic, to make sure the premier had physically visited Government House to meet with the Lieutenant Governor and perform the niceties.

Article content

Article content

Article content

“Is this really happening? Is everybody just assuming this is really happening? He can back out, right? Just turn around the limousine and … go back to being premier of British Columbia?”

Article content

It’s the reaction that has been, to me, fascinating and in some ways encouraging. It is very hard to find flat-out defenders of the early election call — that is, independent commentators who will defend it on an ethical basis. I say this as someone who gives politicians in our Westminsterian political system very wide leeway to “go to the country.” At one time every literate person would have understood what I meant by that phrase: this was the recognized terminology for it — “going to the country” to consult with the people electorally in an unfamiliar, uncertain or dangerous political situation. In his press conference following his Government House visit, Eby evoked this tradition, saying, “There is never a bad time to go to British Columbians to ask the right direction.”

Article content

Article content

Well, all right, buddy boy, but you had better be sure that the public mood supports such consultation in itself. If it appears to be a matter of pure opportunism, or of catching the opposition with its trousers down, you might lose the resulting contest of popular trust pretty easily. So is there a single independent commentator, pundit or informed observer who doesn’t interpret Eby’s snap election as opportunism? I can’t find one: on this issue the left-coast punditariat and its house journals appear to have checked out completely and entered a state of total alienation from the New Democratic Party.

Article content

(Granted, they have never identified with it completely, nor should they, and a lot of them are probably diehard Green voters. It has become slightly difficult in the 21st century, all across Canada, to find people who are New Democrats as a matter of core identity and pride.)

Article content

The Vancouver Sun’s Alec Lazenby was able to find a few NDP “strategists” and veterans who were willing to endorse Eby’s Trump-centric pretext for the election. Very well. Let’s give them credit! The strategy experts would be putting themselves in a risky position if their income actually depended on being right; if Eby loses the poor devils would, in a perfect world, be heavily obliged to find honest non-“strategy” work in the face of the disaster.