Canadians support Alberta’s non-separatism referendum questions that would give province more power: poll

Large crowd gathers for a Canada Day celebration at the Alberta Legislature. Photo by David Bloom /Postmedia

Article content

Put to Canadians outside Alberta, nine of the province’s upcoming referendum questions draw as much support as they do at home, a new poll suggests, and often more.

Article content

However, Jack Jedwab, president of the Association for Canadian Studies, puts the strong support for the referendum questions down to the wording, not necessarily a national appetite for the policies. The finding “says less about a broad national desire to remake the federation than about the way the questions are framed,” he said in an email.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Albertans vote Oct. 19 on 10 referendum questions. Nine of them cover immigration, election rules and the province’s place in the federation. These questions were put to Canadians in a new Leger poll commissioned by the Association for Canadian Studies. The tenth referendum question, which asks whether the government should begin the legal process toward a binding vote on separating from Canada, was not tested.

Article content

Article content

The immigration question asks whether Alberta should take more control over immigration to cut it to more sustainable levels, prioritize economic migrants and give its residents first priority for new jobs. Nationally, 69 per cent said “yes,” ranging from 60 per cent in Manitoba and Saskatchewan, to 78 per cent in Quebec. Alberta sat at 64 per cent, Atlantic Canada at 64 per cent, Ontario at 67 per cent and British Columbia 66 per cent.

Article content

Jedwab wrote in an email that Quebecers are “very open to suggestions that provide more control over immigration,” and that the wording triggers a yes “especially when it’s offered at no cost.”

Article content

Albertans were frequently cooler on their own ballot questions than the rest of the country. On a question requiring newcomers to wait 12 months before qualifying for social supports, Alberta’s 68 per cent was the lowest of any region, against 84 per cent in Atlantic Canada and 75 per cent nationally. On charging non-permanent residents fees for health care and education, Alberta’s 65 per cent again trailed the country, which sat at 73 per cent.

Article content

Article content

The five immigration and election questions drew the strongest support overall, from 69 to 76 per cent nationally, and from 64 to 76 per cent in Alberta. A law making only citizens, permanent residents and approved immigrants eligible for provincial services like health care and schooling drew 74 per cent nationally and 71 per cent in Alberta. Requiring proof of citizenship to vote drew 76 per cent nationally and the same in Alberta. 

Article content

Article content

Atlantic Canada was the most receptive region, topping four of the five immigration questions.

Article content

The four constitutional questions drew less support nationally. Handing a province, rather than Ottawa, the power to pick judges for its higher courts drew 55 per cent support. Abolishing the “unelected Senate” drew 57 per cent support. Giving provincial law priority over federal law in shared areas drew 64 per cent support. The only question to miss a national majority asked whether provinces could opt out of federal programs in areas like health care, while keeping the federal money. Only 47 per cent supported that.

Article content

Quebec ran well ahead of the rest on the constitutional side. It led on abolishing the Senate, at 67 per cent, and on provincial selection of judges (65 per cent). On the opt-out question, its 59 per cent support was one of only two regional majorities, alongside British Columbia (51 per cent). Ontario pulled the other way, sitting lowest on the judges (47 per cent), opt-out (40 per cent) and provincial-law (57 per cent) questions.