Blue Jays drop rubber match against New York Yankees

Sunday's loss snaps a run of seven straight series wins; Toronto will now prepare for critical stretch against sub-.500 teams

Published Aug 23, 2026  •  Last updated 5 minutes ago  •  5 minute read

Yankees' Jazz Chisholm Jr. reacts after hitting a two-run home run during the seventh inning against the Blue Jays at Yankee Stadium on Aug. 23, 2026 in New York. Photo by Sarah Stier /GETTY IMAGES

See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source

Article content

A total of 30 games remain to be played for the Blue Jays, whose improved play has allowed the club to be in the conversation for a wild card in a race that changes daily and figures to remain fluid until the final weekend.

Article content

Article content

The season-ending stretch boils down to 15 games to be played at home, while 15 will be staged on the road.

As of Sunday, the Jays will not face a foe with a winning record, having completed a tough slate that saw the club go toe to toe with AL East rivals Boston, Tampa and New York, three teams comfortably positioned to make the playoffs led by the division-leading Rays.

The lone AL East club the Jays will face down the stretch will be Baltimore, which will be in Toronto for three games before the Orioles play host to the Jays.

On paper, the schedule seems to favour the Jays, at least based on the quality of the opposition, but nothing is taken for granted knowing any loss moving forward will impact the chase for the third and final wild card.

The Jays have experienced this ascension by maintaining baseball’s rigid day-to-day routine and by stringing together series wins.

Article content

Article content

For the most part, the Jays have played clean baseball, able to produce timely hits in key moments, while receiving solid pitching from their starters and relievers.

In Saturday’s 4-3 win, Dylan Cease took a no-hit bid into the seventh inning, while Louis Varland recorded his 29th save.

Sunday’s series rubber match had a different feel, a day when the Jays regrouped from a 2-0 hole only to give up three runs in the sixth inning when pitching wasn’t as sharp.

Despite dropping the game, 8-3, there’s been more signs of improvement than regression.

The series loss did snap a run of seven straight series wins that began in Washington.

Sunday’s game marked the 13th and final regular-season meeting between the Jays and Yankees, who took the season series 7-6.

It also marked the end of a 13-game run against the Red Sox, Rays and Yankees that saw the Jays go 8-5.

How Sunday’s game unraveled was atypical of the Jays’ recent play on both sides of the ball.

And with the schedule about to get soft, the Jays’ margin for error remains slim.

Article content

The following are three takeaways on a day the Yankees would hit two home runs to highlight a 14-hit performance after recording a combined eight hits in the opening two games of the series, a day Alejandro Kirk extended his career-high hit streak to 12, a day Myles Straw recorded two doubles in three at-bats, while scoring a run.

1. So long Soriano

In his fourth start for the Jays and first of the season against the Yankees, Jose Soriano had an uneven day in the Bronx.

Four starts into his tenure with the Jays and the right-hander has yet to flash a form many believed would complement Cease.

The way Shane Bieber has been dealing, the former Cy Young Award winner seems best suited to handle more of a burden.

When Soriano left Sunday’s start, the bases were loaded with none out in the sixth inning in a 2-2 game.

Soriano’s 100-pitch outing featured seven hits yielded, while three walks were issued and seven strikeouts recorded.

On his final pitch tossed on the day, Soriano decided to field a bunt third baseman Kazuma Okamoto was better positioned to handle that resulted in an infield hit to load the bases.

Article content

The Jays caught a break when rookie shortstop George Lombard Jr. failed to handle a routine grounder that had the earmarks of a tailor-made, inning-ending double play.

In all three games, Lombard Jr. committed an error, while Sunday’s miscue was the fourth combined error by the Yankees.

Soriano wasn’t so fortunate when it came to catching a break.

In his three previous starts for the Jays, Soriano gave up a total of five earned runs.

Sunday, Soriano was tagged with five earned runs.

The 100 pitches were the most Soriano has tossed with the Jays.

2. Fishing in the Hudson

When he’s not serving as an opener, Braydon Fisher is often entering games in some form of leverage.

Such was the case Sunday when the righty inherited a bases-loaded dilemma with absolutely no margin for error knowing zero outs had been recorded.

Fisher would get two outs before a walk, his 35th of the season across 65.2 innings, would allow the Yankees to retake the lead.

Once the free pass had been surrendered, Fisher was relieved for Mason Fluharty.

Article content

In a lefty-lefty matchup, Fluharty gave up a two-run single to Ben Rice.

In the home half of the seventh, Jazz Chisholm Jr. took Fluharty deep into right field for a two-run belt, Chisholm Jr.’s fourth hit in the past two games.

Read More

1. 

   SIMMONS SUNDAY: Blue Jays manager John Schneider must be doing something right

2. 

   Blue Jays survive late scare to edge Yankees after Dylan Cease no-hit bid ends in 7th inning

3. Vlad Jr. update

In his second game back from a seven-day stint on the concussion IL, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. went 0-3 before he stepped up to the plate in the eighth inning, one out and a runner at second base with the Jays trailing by five runs.

Credit goes to Vlad Jr. for not allowing his lack of slug or inability to cash in runners in scoring position to compromise his defence at first base, which has been elite.

But he needs to hit and Vlad Jr. hasn’t stepped up in moments that demand it.

Yet another groundout would punctuate an 0-for-4 day.

He returns home hoping to finally hit a homer at Rogers Centre.

Only seven dingers have been produced this season, all on the road.

Vlad Jr. hasn’t gone yard in Toronto in more than one full calendar year, Aug. 17 to be exact when the Texas Rangers were in town.

Up Next

Following Monday’s off day, Jays resume their playoff pursuit by playing host to the Kansas City Royals in a three-game series. K.C. sits last in the AL Central and arrives in Toronto sporting a 22-44 road record. The teams will wrap up their season series when the Jays visit K.C. for a three-game set beginning Sept. 4.

[email protected]

RECOMMENDED VIDEO

Article content