“Beth just got more abusive”: It’s a Shame How Taylor Sheridan Forgot the Best Scene in Yellowstone That Almost Saved the Show

As Shakespeare once quipped, “All the world’s a stage,” and does it seem like the Dutton family is stealing the show in a high-stakes drama that’s gotten more twists than a lasso at a rodeo? With the final episodes of Yellowstone revving up for a thrilling finish, fans are left biting their nails, eager for every juicy detail.

Kelly Reilly in Yellowstone | Credit: Paramount+

Amidst the drama, there’s a particular tug-of-war going on with fans’ feelings about Jamie and Beth. But then there’s the conundrum: why is Beth, who constantly gives Jamie the cold shoulder, being romanticized? One fan even highlights a standout scene where she has a breakdown in Jamie’s car and, in a moment of vulnerability, he comforts her with a heartfelt reassurance that feels like a glimmer of hope for their relationship.

Yellowstone’s Dutton Drama: A Wild Ride of Emotions and Mixed Messages?

When it comes to Yellowstone, the emotional fallout is far from settled. As viewers gear up for the latest escapades of the Dutton family later this year, fans find themselves knee-deep in a philosophical pickle—particularly about Jamie and Beth. 

So, what’s the beef? Well, on one hand, there’s Jamie, who some fans consider a “good guy at heart.” He’s got that classic softy vibe, but here’s the kicker: is the show trying to make us feel sorry for him, or are they gently nudging us to roll our eyes in disapproval? Meanwhile, he’s juggling family chaos and dodging emotional landmines courtesy of Beth.

Wes Bentley and Kelly Reilly in Yellowstone | Credit: Paramount+

Now, let’s talk about that emotional gem from Season 4, Episode 6, where Beth has a breakdown in Jamie’s car. She’s pointing an empty gun at her own head, and Jamie, in a moment of utter sincerity, says, “If hating me stops you from hating yourself, you can hate me. That’s what family is for.”

But alas, that moment of hope went flying out the window, as Beth’s abusive tendencies only ramped up. As illustrated by one fan:

What exactly is the shows attitude towards Jamie?
byu/-kotye- inYellowstonePN

But lo and behold, instead of a blossoming relationship, Beth’s behavior takes a nosedive, leaving viewers feeling like they’ve missed the bus on character growth. Talk about a missed opportunity in Taylor Sheridan’s show—this scene could have been the golden ticket!

And just when you think you’ve seen it all, this fan compares Yellowstone to Twilight. Remember when everyone swooned over Edward and Bella, only to later realize their relationship was as stable as a house of cards in a windstorm? Fans are worried that Yellowstone is on a similar path.

Kelly Reilly Views Beth as Just One Feather in Her Cap

Kelly Reilly in Yellowstone | Credit: Paramount+

As we inch closer to the final showdown in Yellowstone, Kelly Reilly is dusting off her cowboy hat and preparing to step back into the formidable shoes of Beth Dutton. During a conversation with TVLine, the actress made it clear that she’s no stranger to the spotlight. What she’s getting at is that some folks might only know her as a one-trick pony from Yellowstone, but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. She’s been honing her work for three decades, weaving a tapestry of roles that go beyond what meets the eye. 

To quote her:

I don’t really think like that, because look, there may be some people who’ve only ever seen me in Yellowstone, but I’ve been working as an actress for 30 years now.

So, while she may be the flavor of the month for some, she’s got a rich history of performances that paints a much broader picture. Beth Dutton, the one and only daughter of the legendary John Dutton, has been hogging the limelight for five whole seasons now.

Let’s face it: she is one of a kind—a fierce antihero shrouded in mystery, always unpredictable and often leaving chaos in her wake. Will Beth Dutton’s return to the series later this year be a showstopper, or will it be yet another twist in her epic saga? 

The second part of Yellowstone Season 5 will ride onto our screens on November 10, 2024. And for those who can’t wait, you can stream all the Dutton drama on Paramount+.