5 Highest-Rated Crime Thrillers on Disney+

When you think of Disney+, your mind would probably wander to galaxy-spanning space operas, cape-clad superheroes, or animated classics that reek of childhood nostalgia. However, that is not all the platform is about, as it has quietly built up an incredibly fierce library of mature, pulse-pounding adult dramas. 

If you are looking to spend this weekend locked in a state of pure suspense, here are five crime thriller masterpieces that you must watch on the platform. Based on their official Rotten Tomatoes critical approval ratings, here are the five highest-rated crime thrillers streaming on Disney+ right now. 

1 Sovereign (2025) – 95%

Sovereign tells the harrowing, high-stakes story of a chief of police who finds himself locked in an escalating, high-tension standoff with a father and son who identify as Sovereign Citizens. Sovereign Citizens is an anti-government extremist group that believes they are entirely exempt from the laws of the land. 

The film relies heavily on its claustrophobic, pressure-cooker pacing. It explores how ideological fanaticism can completely destroy a family unit. By framing the intense physical manhunt with deep philosophical debates, it elaborates on the deep philosophical debates about the limits of personal liberty. 

Easily one of the most intellectually provocative thrillers on Disney+, the film avoids the easy route of turning its antagonists into cartoonish villains and instead presents them as flawed, complex humans. It deserves a spot on this list because it manages to keep your heart rate elevated through tense dialogue and physical action sequences. 

2 Spy (2015) – 94%

Directed and written by Paul Feig, the spy action crime film may not be a thriller per se, but it surely deserves a spot on this list for its fast pace. Susan Cooper is a brilliant, desk-bound CIA analyst who serves as the unsung brains behind the agency’s most dangerous field missions. 

However, when her suave partner falls off the grid, and another top agent is compromised, Susan volunteers to go deep undercover to infiltrate the inner circle of a deadly international arms dealer and prevent a global nuclear disaster. The action choreography is shockingly brutal, the stakes are real, and the criminal underworld feels appropriately dangerous beneath the constant barrage of hilarious gags. 

The film works because it treats its narrative beats with complete seriousness, while the jokes land without compromising the seriousness of the film. The reason why this film works out is that it is genuinely exhilarating while simultaneously making you laugh out loud. If you are done with boring spy thrillers and need a fun palate cleanser, this one is for you!

3 The Order (2024) – 93%

The crime thriller The Order is based on the 1989 non-fiction book The Silent Brotherhood by Kevin Flynn and Gary Gerhardt. The film revolves around an FBI agent who chases after a white supremacist terrorist group.

Starring Jude Law and Nicholas Hoult, it moves away from a standard crime film into a sophisticated, highly organized domestic terrorist cell plotting an armed revolution against the United States government. What is commendable is its reliance on psychological warfare as the agents try to take down the extremist leader.

The film stands out among true-crime adaptations because it plays out as an atmospheric, slow-burning character study rather than a flashy action movie. From balancing high-stakes historical significance to the deeply intimate performances of the leads, this film surely deserves a spot on your watchlist.

4 Strange Harvest (2025) – 92%

Strange Harvest is a mockumentary crime horror film that follows a detective pair following a serial killer who goes by the name of Mr Shiny. The serial killer reappears after a nearly two-decade-long absence, pulling the two veteran detectives out of retirement to track him. 

The murders are bizarre and ritualistic, mirroring the events that took place years ago. Slowly, as the film unfolds, it becomes more than a folklore thriller with its new-noir tension. From patient dialogue to a moody visual palette, its atmospheric vibe works well to deliver a deeply analytical crime story without sacrificing on its psychological elements. 

What makes the film stand out is that it is not your average horror thriller centered around crime, but how it strays away from the usual modern clichés and jump scares. The way it treats its settings is praiseworthy because it captures the exact high-stakes, grim, and intellectual energy of critically acclaimed projects like True Detective. If you want a satisfying yet chilling experience that transports you within its claustrophobic cosmic horror, this is for you!

5 Sicario (2015) – 91%

One of the best films that Denis Villeneuve ever directed, Sicario is written by Taylor Sheridan, marking his screenwriting debut. With a stellar cast and a story centered around a Mexican drug cartel, it is everything you demand from a perfect action crime thriller. 

It follows FBI agent Kate Macer, who is recruited by an elite government task force leader to aid in the escalating war against drugs. Slowly, the film turns into a lawless nightmare while throwing light on how the government’s tactics are just as brutal as the cartels they are hunting to destroy. 

No less than a cinematic masterpiece, it is an unrelenting, white-knuckle exploration of the moral gray areas of geographical warfare. The brilliance of the film lies in how Villeneuve weaponizes the audience’s perspective to deliver a cynical tale of systematic violence. If you haven’t seen it, well, you are missing out big time. So get your device out and watch it now!

Each of these films has something unique to offer when it comes to the crime thriller genre. Whether it is the unhinged comedic Spy or the gloom-inducing Strange Harvest, each of these films deserves applause for how they tackle and present their case. 

So which of these films would you be watching next? Let us know in the comments below!

All of these films are available for streaming on Disney+.