10 Shows to Watch If You Liked Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen 

A slow-burning horror and unsettling narrative seldom make as big an impact as Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen did on viewers. The gradual psychological unravelling, coupled with a suspenseful story, made viewers feel equal parts dread and thrill. The below shows thrive on ambiguity, atmosphere, and the creeping sense that reality itself might be slipping, making them perfect one-night watches. More than jump scares and ugly monsters, the shows build on an uncomfortable story of fractured psyches, relationships, and past traumas. 

What ties all these shows together isn’t just horror, it’s uncertainty. In many ways, that’s what makes Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen so effective because it doesn’t feed the plot to the audience on a silver platter and makes them work for it. So if you also love that same eerie aftertaste, here are a few shows that can satiate your hunger for more.

1 Harper’s Island – Prime Video and AppleTV+

Set against the serene backdrop of a destination wedding that gives a sense of serenity on first look, Harper’s Island wastes no time plunging into chaos. Guests begin dying one by one, and what initially feels like a classic whodunit evolves into something far more sinister.

Much like Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen, the show makes perfect use of paranoia and the fear that danger is hiding in plain sight. The characters feel trapped on the island with a danger looming over them and nowhere to run. This tension and the overall setting of the story are very similar to Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen, where people are caught in a tough spot right before a wedding.

2 Midnight Mass – Netflix

From the brilliant mind of Mike Flanagan, this series, Midnight Mass, gives viewers a blend of faith, grief, and horror into a deeply unsettling narrative. When a mysterious priest arrives in a dying town, with the promise of miracles and a better life, he actually unravels something darker, exploring secrets that were hidden for years. 

Trust Flanagan to make discomfort one of the plot devices in the show and weave a slow-burning dread that lingers long after the show is over. Both shows mirror philosophical undertones, the existential unease that seeps into your thoughts rather than shocks your senses.

3 The Haunting of Hill House – Netflix

With time jumps, broken characters, and one dark night that changed everything, The Haunting of Hill House offers horror unlike anything we’ve seen before. A fractured family revisits the trauma of their childhood, the time they spent in a haunted house that may never let them go. The show explores the impact of early experiences on kids and how they shape them as adults. 

Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen and The Haunting of Hill House both delve into memory, grief, and psychological decay. The blurred lines between past and present to create a deeply unsettling narrative structure are found in both shows.

4 Brand New Cherry Flavor – Netflix

Set in 1990s Los Angeles, Brand New Cherry Flavor is about a filmmaker who enters a pact with a mysterious witch to get revenge. However, the events slowly tumble towards a grotesque nightmare with elements of magic, debauchery, and chaos.

If you reveled in the unpredictability and surreal dread of Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen, this show leans fully into it. With a deliberately disorienting plot, the show will leave you confused over what you just watched. 

5 Marianne – Netflix

Marianne blurs the lines between fact and fiction as a ghost of nightmares emerges in reality to plague a horror novelist. She discovers that the witch haunting her dreams is real and far more powerful than she imagined. This leads her to a rabbit hole of past traumas and experiences that she never truly recovered from. 

Psychological terror and the idea that imagination can bleed into reality are common themes in both shows, offering a view into psyches that have a hard time staying grounded in reality. It’s relentless and deeply disturbing, much like the tone you’re probably looking for.

6 Evil – Paramount+

A skeptical psychologist, a priest-in-training, and a tech expert investigate unexplained phenomena, walking the line between science and the supernatural. With every step they take and every possible breakthrough they come across, viewers are put on the edge of their seats to watch the uncertain elements take shape. 

The same ambiguity is key here, making viewers wonder whether the horrors are real or if they are psychological. That tension aligns perfectly with the tense tone that defines Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen.

7 The Sinner – Netflix

Ever wondered how seemingly ordinary people commit atrocious crimes that leave their peers speechless? What makes them go to such lengths and defy every character trait they have ever shown? This show explores exactly this line of thought as each season dissects a crime by focusing not on who did it, but why.

Both shows play jumprope with the line between sanity and insanity with a psychological deep dive, making this a strong match. It’s less about ghosts and ghouls that signify external horror and more about the darkness within people, which often ends up being more unsettling.

8 Behind Her Eyes – Netflix

If you’re dying to experience the same “wait, what just happened?” energy as Something Very Bad Is Going To Happen, then waste no time in bingeing this series. A single mother becomes involved in a complicated relationship with her boss and his enigmatic wife. What seems to be a straightforward affair in the beginning slowly leads to a shocking supernatural twist.

Both shows deliver a shocking twist in the end, where you will wonder how you didn’t see it coming. The psyche of the characters and how they deal with the horrors in front of them is also very similar in Behind Her Eyes and Something Very Bad Is Going To Happen.

9 Chambers – Netflix

After receiving a heart transplant, a young woman becomes obsessed with the mysterious death of her donor and begins to change in disturbing ways. She adopts mannerisms and character traits from the deceased donor, marking a shift in her psyche, too. 

Themes of identity, body horror, and psychological transformation create a deeply uneasy atmosphere in both shows. Similarly, it’s the intimate horror that creeps under your skin.

10 Archive 81- Netflix

When an archivist restores damaged videotapes, they uncover a chilling conspiracy tied to a missing filmmaker and a cult. The gradual unravelling of truth and the people involved is very similar to Something Very Bad Is Going To Happen.

Found-footage aesthetics, layered timelines, and creeping dread make this a near-perfect tonal match to the show. It builds a sense of inevitability that feels impossible to escape.

Here is a brief summary of the titles and where to watch them:

Show	Streaming Platform	IMDb Score (As of March 29, 2026)
Harper’s Island	Prime Video / AppleTV+ (rent)	7.4/10
Midnight Mass	Netflix	7.7/10
The Haunting of Hill House	Netflix	8.5/10
Brand New Cherry Flavor	Netflix	7.1/10
Marianne	Netflix	7.3/10
Evil	Paramount+	7.7/10
The Sinner	Netflix	7.8/10
Behind Her Eyes	Netflix	7.2/10
Chambers	Netflix	6.5/10
Archive 81	Netflix	7.3/10

Are you ready to stream these supernatural shows and immerse yourself in dread? Tell us your thoughts in the comments!