Why horror-comedy hit ‘Widow’s Bay’ is the TV show of the moment

Author of the article:

Washington Post

Jen Chaney, The Washington Post

Published Jun 24, 2026  •  4 minute read

Matthew Rhys stars in Apple's 'Widow's Bay.' Photo by Apple TV

See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source

Article content

After debuting quietly on Apple TV in late April, “Widow’s Bay,” created by “Parks and Recreation” veteran Katie Dippold, has become the sleeper streaming hit that seemingly everyone is talking about.

Article content

Article content

“Everyone Is Watching ‘Widow’s Bay,'” read a recent Vulture headline. The Guardian declared that “it has become ‘a buzzy water cooler hit.'” And Apple announced last week that the show has been picked up for a second season and that Dippold has been signed to a multiyear development deal.

What is it about this show that’s resonating with viewers? There are the obvious things: It’s a very well-written, tonally agile work of television that is funny, surprising and stacked with fantastic, seasoned actors. (In addition to Matthew Rhys, its ensemble includes Stephen Root, Jeff Hiller, Dale Dickey, Betty Gilpin, Hamish Linklater and a breakout performance from British actress Kate O’Flynn.)

But I think there’s another reason “Widow’s Bay” is having a moment: It asks us to digest its horrors by making us laugh at the things that scare us, which is the same coping mechanism that helps many of us process the nightmares that come with being alive in 2026.

Article content

Article content

In Widow’s Bay, the bad things that happen on a regular basis are just part of the fabric of life. Serial killers, murderous sea hags, life-threatening storms, haunted hotels and persistent talk of a curse are just a few. That’s to say nothing of all the ghastly stories that define the island’s history.

In the first episode, while trying to charm a New York Times travel writer in the hopes of boosting tourism, Mayor Tom Loftis (Rhys) insists that stories about cannibalism on the island are just myths. He says this while standing in front of a large display of an old local newspaper with a headline that reads, “Cannibalism in God’s House.” “I don’t think that’s right,” Tom says when the reporter asks about that headline. “I mean, it’s in a framed article inside the historical society,” the reporter responds. “Did they immediately turn to cannibalism?” Tom asks. Then he pauses to read a bit of the text. “No,” he says confidently. “That took four days.”

Dippold and her writers understand how amusing it can be when politicians try to downplay the awfulness of a situation. The contrast between the obvious truth and the denial of said truth is maddening and, in real life, quite dangerous. But it is also inherently hilarious, something that President Donald Trump shows us over and over again when he says that grocery prices are down (they’re not) or insists that his father was born in Germany (he was not). “Widow’s Bay” gets this.

Article content

There are certainly moments in the show that are genuinely frightening and in which the characters are, appropriately, quite frightened, but there is always an acknowledgment of the absurdity in those moments.

Take the eighth episode, “Your Baggage,” an homage to John Carpenter’s “Halloween” in which O’Flynn’s Patricia runs screaming through the streets to escape a murderer known only as the Boogeyman. On one hand, you’re on the edge of your seat hoping that Patricia will escape or that a neighbor will come to her aid. On the other, you can’t stop laughing because she is running around panic-stricken in a pair of mukluks while the Boogeyman slowly, sloooowly lumbers multiple yards behind her.

Try to come up with a better metaphor for how it has felt to be a Democrat during the Trump era than the sight of a woman yelling for help while a dude with absolutely zero stamina gets closer and closer to ending her life and absolutely no one will listen to her. No, really. Go ahead.

Article content

Horror is a perennially popular genre, but it is definitely popping right now. At the box office, three of the most popular movies in the country – “Obsession,” “Backrooms” and “Scary Movie” – are designed to unnerve. Apple also recently released an episodic take on “Cape Fear,” inspired by Martin Scorsese’s 1991 remake of the 1962 original. But none of these, and yes, I am including “Scary Movie,” are threading the needle between farce and fright with as much intelligence and authority as “Widow’s Bay.” Honestly, I can’t think of any film or television show in recent memory that has done this so consistently well.

But “Widow’s Bay” doesn’t merely poke fun at the things and people that terrorize us. It also examines how to cope with feeling on edge 24 hours a day and does so in ways that are meaningful and poignant.

In the season finale, which dropped Wednesday, Tom has a long conversation with Ruth (the great K Callan), an elderly native of the island who works as his assistant. She tells him that you can’t control the bad things in life, and then reads a long quote from Tennessee Williams that she has sewn into a cross-stitch. Unfortunately the quote is so long that it barely fits on the cross-stitch. But it says, in part: “We live in a perpetually burning building, and what we must save from it, all the time, is love.”

Article content

“Widow’s Bay” ultimately encourages us to acknowledge life’s ongoing devastation while still making room for joy and humour. It shows us how important it is to be there for our fellow humans, even when the systems in place – whether they’re represented by superstitions or government policy – don’t value humanity. At a moment when we really need to be reminded of this, “Widow’s Bay” admits that the world is terrifying, but that whoever created it also has a hell of a sense of humour. So we may as well try to laugh as often as we gasp.

Read More

1. 

   Javier Bardem, Amy Adams and Patrick Wilson talk 'Cape Fear' remake

2. 

   Jon Hamm steals spotlight with role on 'Your Friends & Neighbors'

Article content