Trump’s Hormuz blockade threat could backfire: analysts

U.S. President Donald Trump has threatened a U.S. naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, but will that help him get the upper hand with Iran? Photo by Jim WATSON /AFP

Article content

The failure of U.S.-Iran peace talks has left President Donald Trump with several unpalatable options, as analysts say his order to blockade the strategic Strait of Hormuz could further complicate his next move.

Article content

Any hopes that U.S. Vice President JD Vance would emerge from the marathon day of negotiations with top Iranian officials with a deal to end a war that has rippled across the Middle East were dashed when he left Pakistan empty-handed.

Article content

Article content

Protracted talks would undermine Trump’s insistence that Iran has “no cards” left to play, while ramping up military action would expose U.S. forces to heightened risk and could alienate voters — already angry with surging gas prices — ahead of midterm elections.

Article content

And the blockade of the strait through which a fifth of the world’s oil moves would do little to ease global economic jitters.

Article content

For Brian Katulis, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute, Trump’s propensity to talk off the cuff and make threats — what he called the president’s “carnival barker” style — leaves his close aides scrambling to chart a path forward.

Article content

“He may be simply buying more time to move in more military assets or because he doesn’t know what else to do. I wouldn’t call it a strategy; it is a military-centric approach without strategy,” Katulis told AFP.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Shibley Telhami, a professor of peace and development at the University of Maryland and a fellow at the Brookings Institution think tank, says the threat of a blockade was “bewildering and seems self-defeating.”

Article content

Article content

“Iran already has no trust in Trump,” Telhami told AFP. “Hard to understate what this makes of what’s left of America’s global credibility.”

Article content

‘Untrustworthy and duplicitous’

Article content

Iran’s powerful Revolutionary Guards on Sunday pledged that Tehran’s enemies would be trapped in a “deadly vortex” if they were to make a wrong move in the strait.

Article content

Danny Citrinowicz, a fellow at Israel’s Institute for National Security Studies, said a naval blockade would indeed expose U.S. forces to increased risk.

Article content

“There is little reason to believe that a blockade would force Iranian capitulation. If anything, Iran’s demonstrated resilience thus far suggests the opposite,” Citrinowicz wrote on X.

Article content

“Iran’s geographic scale and military capabilities mean that sustaining such an operation would demand substantial and prolonged allocation of American resources.”

Article content

And such a prolonged military engagement may not sit well with Americans who say they are worried and stressed about the conflict, which began in late February.

Article content

Article content

A CBS News poll published Sunday revealed that worry, stress and anger far outweigh safety and confidence when those polled were asked how they feel about the war.

Article content

Article content

More than 80 percent of respondents said the United States should seek to reopen the strait and improve global access to oil, which would bring gas prices down, and make sure that the Iranian people are “free.”

Article content

But fewer than 10 percent said they believed those goals had been achieved.

Article content

“I don’t see how, 40-plus days into this war, that we are safer, that our allies are safer. I’m not even sure Israel is safer,” Democratic U.S. Senator Mark Warner said Sunday on CNN’s “State of the Union” talk show.

Article content

“I don’t understand how blockading the strait is going to somehow push the Iranians into opening it. I don’t get the connection there.”

Article content

So if the blockade is not an answer, what about more negotiations?

Article content

Democratic Senator Tim Kaine suggested that would not be an easy path, given that Trump removed the U.S. from a 2015 accord reached by Tehran and world powers on restricting its nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief.