“That idea stuck in the back of our minds”: A Canceled Uncharted 2 Concept Sparked The Last of Us After Neil Druckmann Couldn’t Shake it Off

The Last of Us is a beloved action-adventure game set in the post-apocalyptic world. The game boasts impressive graphics and engaging gameplay, but what makes this game feel more immersive and connected are the 2 main characters: Joel and Ellie. The bond both of them created during their epic journey of escaping the military quarantine zone is what makes the game so epic.

The bond between Joel and Ellie immersed players into the game’s narrative. | Image Credit: Naughty Dog

However, not many fans know that the idea behind Ellie came when Neil Druckmann, Lead Writer and Co-Director, was discussing a potential female mute character in Uncharted 2 (which didn’t happen). However, the idea remained stuck in his mind, so when discussing the next project (The Last of Us), the game’s concept and the character of Ellie were born, the rest is history.

How Revisiting an Old Concept Gave Birth to The Last of Us

Druckmann came up with the core idea of the game when brainstorming for previous projects. | Image Credit: Naughty Dog

After the great reception of The Last of Us, Neil Druckmann revealed in an interview how he got the inspiration for Ellie and the complex relationship she will have with Joel, the main character. He stated that during the development of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, he and his creative partner Bruce Straley used to spend time brainstorming and exploring a variety of gameplay and story scenarios.

Among all the ideas they discussed, one sequence they quite liked, referring to it as The Mute Girl. This concept was envisioned as a dramatic scenario set in a war-torn city where the Uncharted’s protagonist, Nathan Drake will encounter a mute teenage girl as part of a rebel group. Slowly, Drake would connect with the mute girl through actions (like climbing roofs) rather not words.

This silent but intense bond formed through these subtle interactions was going to be a central element of the gameplay experience. But, the concept was shelved and didn’t make it into Uncharted 2. However, the concept left a long-lasting impression on Druckmann, so when they were discussing the next Naughty Dog project, they revisited the idea. His exact words were:

That idea stuck in the back of our minds when we started discussing our next project. That morphed into a question: could you build an entire game around this concept of meeting a character really early on and forming a bond that would evolve and shift.

Enter The Last of Us, a critically acclaimed game that captured millions of players’ hearts with its deep, evolving bond between Joel and Ellie as they shared various harsh experiences and emotional engagement. The gameplay along with this deep character development left a huge impression on the players, who continue to remember the epic experience and want more.

Significance of Nurturing and Reimagining Creative Ideas

Druckmann showed that sometimes forgotten ideas can be the most impactful if nurtured properly. | Image Credit: Naughty Dog

Even though gaming is a fast-evolving industry, The Last of Us‘ success shows that initial concepts, even when shelved, can evolve into groundbreaking innovations if nurtured properly. Reworking and reimagining past ideas in a new and innovative way has the potential to break the norm, showcasing brilliance.

Neil Druckmann and Bruce Straley’s persistence in revisiting the abandoned Mute Girl concept in Uncharted 2 showed how a shelved idea, when reworked and expanded upon, can bring out unexpected results.

Both Druckmann and Straley transformed a simple concept into a deeply emotional and immersive narrative, proving that creativity requires dedication and adaptation.

As gamers eagerly wait for any news about the potential third installment in the series, they will be surprised to learn that the core idea of The Last of Us was a rejected plot point. Ultimately, all the credit goes to Druckmann, whose determination to see the potential in an old concept, cemented the title as a landmark in video game history.

What do you enjoy the most about this series? Tell us in the comment section below.