John Ivison: The loss of Scott Aitchison is a grim warning for Conservatives

Article content

As a former mayor of Huntsville, he had no time for NIMBYism and his leadership campaign proposed tying municipal funding to building more homes.

Article content

His departure is more significant than merely the loss of an able, fair-minded MP.

Article content

Rather, it is indicative of a Conservative party whose reach is ebbing.

Article content

Moreover, it suggests the 2025 election result was a high-water bulge and that support levels are likely to continue dropping steadily.

Article content

In 2000, the Canadian Alliance scored a breakthrough of sorts, electing 66 MPs, including two in Ontario, with the backing of one-quarter of the electorate. Prior to that election, the Alliance and its predecessor, Reform, were considered western protest parties. That election result provided a base from which to grow. Within two years, Stephen Harper had defeated Stockwell Day to become leader and within three, the right had united to form the modern Conservative party.

Article content

Harper’s greatest achievement was building a national coalition that not only won and retained power in 2006, 2008 and 2011 but proved robust enough to endure defeat.

Article content

Article content

In his book, Harper’s Team, former Conservative campaign organizer Tom Flanagan said Conservatives had never really recovered from the death of Sir John A. Macdonald in 1891 because no leader had been able to hold together a durable coalition. Robert Borden, R. B. Bennett, John Diefenbaker and Brian Mulroney had recorded temporary successes, but all ended not just in defeat but in disaster, Flanagan wrote, leaving the party worse off than it was before.

Article content

Harper, by contrast, left a party with 99 MPs and money in the bank in 2015. “It was sad but not tragic,” in the words of one former cabinet minister.

Article content

Writing in 2007, Flanagan urged that his party follow “10 Commandments” to cement the Conservatives as Canada’s natural governing party.

Article content

They included unity among the different strands of conservatism; moderation; inclusion; and the ability to learn from experience.

Article content

Scott Aitchison takes part in a Conservative Party of Canada leadership debate in Edmonton on May 11, 2022. Photo by Greg Southam/Postmedia

Article content

Conservatives lose if the others line up together, Flanagan said. “We must avoid being painted as the Great Satan of Canadian politics, as happened with the Reform Party and Canadian Alliance.”

Article content

If Conservatives are perceived as a threat to civilization by fearful moderates or left-wing voters, those people are likely to vote Liberal, he said.

Article content

Article content

“We can’t win if we veer too far to the right of the median voter.”

Article content

Poilievre appears to have forgotten or abandoned those prescriptions as he leads the party back to Canadian Alliance levels of support.

Article content

This week’s Nanos opinion poll rated Liberal support in Ontario at nearly 60 per cent, with the Conservatives at around half that level. Not many of the party’s 50 MPs would survive that kind of electoral tidal wave.

Article content

The problem is not local to the Conservative party.

Article content

Canadian democracy is not well served by having one party or leader as dominant, as will become the case if the Conservatives do not arrest their decline.

Article content

“History proves that freedom always dies when criticism ends,” Diefenbaker once said. “The Opposition must … find fault, suggest amendments, ask questions and elicit information, arouse, educate and mold public opinion by voice and vote.”

Article content

Even after Aitchison’s departure, the Conservatives will have able men and women capable of doing these things. But the party is sorely lacking the leadership needed to make a convincing case that it should be returned to power.

Article content

National Post

Article content

Article content