Interior design: Kitchen islands vs. peninsulas

Peninsulas offer many of the same benefits as an island, as seen in this rendering by Soda Pop Design Inc. Photo by SUPPLIED

Article content

The open-concept kitchen has long been a must-have for many homeowners and with it, an island that serves as the focal point. It can be designed for a specific purpose like a prep station with a second sink, as a cooking centre with a built-in range or as a multifunctional hub for dining, entertaining and doing homework.

Article content

As the design landscape continues to evolve, however, peninsulas are quietly making a comeback for numerous reasons. For starters, they offer many of the same benefits as an island, including additional workspace, seating and a place to gather.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Kitchen islands aren’t disappearing but are no longer a must-have like they once were, designer Cynthia Soda reports. Photo by MIKE CHAJEKI PHOTOGRAPHY

Article content

“But because they’re connected to the perimeter cabinetry, they often work much better in smaller or narrower kitchens,” says Cynthia Soda, founder and principal designer of Soda Pop Design Inc. in Stouffville. (A search of the internet suggests the biggest disadvantage of a peninsula is that it doesn’t allow movement all the way around it, making it more prone to traffic jams than islands.)

Article content

Breakfast nook

Article content

“Another option we love in small spaces is a galley kitchen with a breakfast nook, a peninsula design with a simple extension to allow for seating, or an L- or U-shaped design combined with a small table,” Soda says. “It creates a more relaxed, flexible dining area that still feels connected to the kitchen. In some homes, this can actually feel more inviting and practical than a traditional island with stools.”  

Article content

Still, that hardly means kitchen islands are a design feature whose time has come. “Kitchen islands aren’t disappearing; they’re simply no longer the automatic answer they once were,” she says.

Article content

That may come as a surprise to many homeowners. After all, incorporating an island – and sometimes even two – was “almost expected” in every kitchen renovation whether they were the best choice or not, she notes. “What we’re seeing now is a shift toward more thoughtful planning.”

Article content

Article content

Function

Article content

“Designers and homeowners are asking whether an island genuinely improves how the kitchen functions, rather than assuming it’s a must-have. In some kitchens, an island is still the perfect solution. In others, different layouts can create better flow and more usable storage and counter space.”

Article content

Certainly, islands offer many benefits. “The biggest advantage of an island is that it creates a natural gathering point in the kitchen. It offers additional workspace, casual seating and often becomes the social hub of the home,” Soda says.

Article content

But there are also limitations to an island, which is typically more expensive to install than a peninsula and can sometimes feel like an obstacle because it requires a considerable footprint to function properly. “If the kitchen isn’t large enough, an island can actually disrupt circulation and make the room feel cramped rather than open,” she say. “An island only works when the kitchen truly has the space for it – otherwise, it can create more congestion than convenience.”  

Article content

Consider, for example, the struggles you may face if the dishwasher door is open and you’re trying to make your way between it and the counter. “They also tend to become catchalls for everyday clutter if they’re not carefully designed with storage and function in mind.”