Air Transat cabin crew can’t get high on their own time due to safety risks: labour arbitrator

An Air Transat Airbus A321 takes off at Trudeau Airport in Montreal. Photo by John Mahoney/Postmedia

Article content

OTTAWA — Air Transat cabin crews may be at 30,000 feet when they’re working, but a recent labour decision confirmed they can’t ever get high on their personal time.

Article content

In a ruling issued earlier this month, arbitrator Nathalie Massicotte settled an ongoing question since Canada legalized cannabis in 2018: can airlines bar employees in “high-risk” positions from consuming drugs at any point on or off duty?

Article content

Article content

Article content

The answer is yes, Massicotte ruled, upholding Air Transat’s policy implemented shortly after cannabis was legalized that bans certain employees such as flight and cabin crew members from consuming drugs at any time, even on their days off.

Article content

Article content

The decision is likely the first of its kind and, though it settles a dispute between Air Transat and its unionized staff, will likely impact all other Canadian airlines that have implemented a similar policy for their aircrews, which includes pilots, first officers and other cabin staff.

Article content

“I am of the view that passenger safety on an aircraft must take precedence over the right to privacy in this case, and more specifically, the possibility for cabin crew to consume cannabis when they are not on duty,” Massicotte wrote.

Article content

The provisions of the policy challenged by the union represent a reasonable balance when weighing the flight attendants’ right to privacy against the employer’s obligation to ensure safety on its flights, she said.

Article content

The policy was grieved by the Canadian Union of Public Employees local representing flight attendants and service directors, otherwise known as the cabin crew.

Article content

Article content

In a statement, Air Transat spokesperson Stéphanie Dussault said the company was satisfied with the decision, which upheld a policy that was implemented in one shape or another across the industry in Canada.

Article content

Article content

“Our priority has always been, and will remain, the safety of our flight operations, as much for our employees as for our passengers and the public. Our policy aims to ensure that the impacted employees are able to perform their duties at all times,” Dussault said in an email.

Article content

But the president of CUPE’s Air Transat local, Marie-Hélène Nadeau, argued that the policy remains “abusive and excessively intrusive” in regard to her members’ privacy.

Article content

“It could lead to disciplinary action against flight attendants who have consumed cannabis several days, or even weeks, before a workday,” she said in an emailed statement.

Article content

Nadeau also suggested that the union would be requesting an increase in compensation for its members in light of Air Transat’s argument that flight attendants’ jobs are so sensitive that they require “extreme discipline” even outside of work.

Article content

“Since this is the employer’s position, they will have to compensate our members accordingly,” Nadeau wrote.