10 Underrated Horror Shows Like From, Ranked (& Where to Watch Them)

Credits:- HBO, Peacock, AMC

Away from light-hearted comedies and subtle mysteries, sometimes we need a good horror show to jolt us back to life. From eerie atmospheres to heart-stopping jump scares, the horror genre is perfect for breaking the monotony of life and transporting viewers into another realm altogether. 

Fans of the slow-burning dread often find themselves drawn to shows like From, which offer psychological terror and supernatural intrigue on a silver platter. If you’re on the lookout for more stories that leave you wanting more with every episode, this list ranks ten not-so-famous gems that deserve your attention. The rankings are based on how similar each show is to From and on how the intermingling themes can offer a similar vibe to fans who loved the show.

10 The Night Of – Max

When a college student stops to give a lift to a random stranger, his life undergoes an upheaval following a brutal murder. The Night Of may not be a straightforward horror series, but its gripping narrative and edge-of-your-seat suspense resonate with viewers on another level. The show dives into the criminal justice system, portraying the psychological toll of incarceration and the ambiguity of truth.

While not a traditional horror series, it mirrors From in its suffocating atmosphere and constant sense of dread. Both shows trap the lead characters in environments where escape feels impossible. That burgeoning sense of being trapped slowly takes a toll on the character’s psyche, as the unraveling of the truth leaves them tense and on edge.

9 Station Eleven – Max

Station Eleven explores a post-apocalyptic world following a devastating pandemic, weaving multiple timelines and interconnected characters focused on survival. The world has gone up in proverbial flames after a terrible flu, and the remaining survivors are trying to rebuild it from the ground up. The series uses emotional storytelling against the backdrop of haunting visuals and existential themes to aptly land the ensuing story.

Like From, the show thrives on mystery and fragmented storytelling. Both series focus on communities struggling to survive under unusual circumstances, with characters forming unlikely bonds as they confront various threats. The sense of unpredictability that keeps you up at night makes both shows emotionally and psychologically intense.

8 Night Sky – Prime Video

Things go horribly wrong in the series Night Sky when an elderly couple harbors a secret portal to another planet in their backyard. As others begin to uncover the mystery, their quiet lives are uprooted, and they face terrible consequences as the situation unfolds. 

The show shares From’s fascination with unexplained phenomena and hidden worlds. Both narratives explore characters as they try to make sense of forces beyond human comprehension. Along with shudder-inducing horror, the story also uses human drama and supernatural mystery to accentuate the show’s overall vibe. The slow pacing and eerie revelations create a hauntingly immersive experience in both shows.

7 Harlan Coben’s Shelter – Prime Video

Based on the book of the same name, Harlan Coben’s Shelter series hinges on mystery to showcase inexplicable events that lead to the discovery of secrets and lies that have remained hidden. When Mickey learns that his father is not really dead, he embarks on an adventure to uncover the truth. The series mixes coming-of-age elements with suspenseful mystery.

Shelter may not be a complete horror series, but like From, it revolves around a central mystery that pulls in a diverse group of characters. Both series highlight how ordinary people respond to extraordinary situations as secrets gradually surface. 

6 Hysteria! – Peacock

Going a step beyond the usual horror mania, Hysteria! is a genre-bending series set during the “Satanic Panic” era. The show uses horror and dark humor to drive the story home, where a group of teens gets entangled in supernatural accusations and real danger.

The exploration of paranoia and fear within a community is similar in both From and Hysteria!. Both shows depict how quickly trust can erode in the face of unexplained events, and how fear can become as dangerous as the threat itself. 

5 Into The Dark – Hulu

Into The Dark is an anthology horror series where each episode tells a standalone story tied to a holiday, exploring different facets of fear, from psychological terror to supernatural horror. Eerie environments and quirky characters make each story interesting as we get to the bottom of the mystery, episode by episode.

Though structured differently, From’s commitment to unsettling storytelling is evident in this show as well. Both stories experiment with tone and atmosphere, often placing characters in confined or high-stakes situations. The unpredictability and willingness to explore darker themes are also similar in both.

4 Teacup – Peacock

When a group of strangers is forced together in a mysterious and increasingly dangerous situation, reality begins to blur, and survival becomes uncertain. Teacup promises to ignite discomfort and an unsettling feeling with each turn of the story. 

This premise is pretty close to From, with its focus on a group trapped in a weird scenario. Both series rely on character interactions, hidden motives, and escalating supernatural elements to drive the narrative. The built-up tension and layered mysteries feel strikingly alike in the two shows.

3 Them – AppleTV

Another anthology series on the list is Them, which examines terror through the lens of social issues, beginning with a Black family moving into an all-white neighborhood where both human and supernatural horrors await. The psychological elements in the series can sometimes overpower the horror, but the story eventually delivers a grounded narrative.

Like From, both series explore how the environment shapes fear, with the characters’ psyches as the central theme. The emotional intensity driven by each character, their innate fear, and complex storytelling come together to make the series entirely bingeable.

2 The Outsider – Max

If murders turning into supernatural mysteries is your jam, then binge The Outsider today! Based on a Stephen King novel, it seamlessly blends crime and horror as a detective becomes entangled in a supernatural, inexplicable investigation.

This series strongly echoes From through its balance of real storytelling with supernatural terror. Both shows feature troubled characters grappling with events that defy logic, leading to a slow-burning uncovering of truth. 

1 The Terror – Prime Video

A doomed Arctic expedition is featured in The Terror where the crew faces not only brutal conditions but also a mysterious and deadly presence stalking them. Each season presents a different historical horror tale, keeping up with the demands of fans who wish to immerse themselves in varied, unsettling narratives.

At its core, The Terror shares From’s themes of isolation, survival, and unknown threats. Both shows trap characters in hostile environments that seem to be far from the realities they know. The combination of psychological strain, supernatural elements, and ensemble storytelling makes it the closest match on this list.

Show Name	IMDb Rating – as of April 15, 2026	Rotten Tomatoes Rating – as of April 15, 2026	Streaming Platform
The Night Of	8.5	94%	Max
Station Eleven	7.6	98%	Max
Night Sky	7.3	74%	Prime Video
Shelter	6.5	65%	Prime Video
Hysteria!	6.8	70%	Peacock
Into The Dark	6.3	75%	Hulu
Teacup	6.9	72%	Peacock
Them	7.4	59%	AppleTV
The Outsider	7.7	91%	Max
The Terror	8.0	94%	Prime Video

Are you ready to binge these incredible horror and mystery shows? Share your thoughts in the comments!