A New York Times (NYT) communicative suggesting that immoderate of Iran’s dams and h2o infrastructure whitethorn person been built to enactment the country’s rocket programme has sparked fierce backlash, with commentators informing the study could assistance warrant further attacks connected civilian facilities.
The contention comes arsenic Washington threatens renewed subject enactment against Iran, pursuing months of warfare that person already near the country’s vigor facilities, bridges, h2o infrastructure and different civilian sites damaged.
“The baseless allegations seeking to nexus Iran’s dams to rocket bases represent yet different illustration of a malicious run to manufacture propaganda and information pretexts aimed astatine justifying attacks connected a country’s captious infrastructure,” Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Baghaei said successful a station connected X.
The paper has defended its reporting, insisting it accurately represented the views of its experts.
However, respective experts quoted by the work person publically challenged the implications of the investigation, questioning the grounds down the projected nexus betwixt dams and subject installations.
The contention has besides revived memories of the NYT’s reporting successful the lead-up to the 2003 US penetration of Iraq, erstwhile the paper’s journalists helped amplify claims astir Saddam Hussein’s alleged weapons of wide demolition that aboriginal proved unfounded.
What did the NYT study say?
Published connected Tuesday, the story, headlined “War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason”, examined whether Iran’s extended web of dams, pipelines and water-transfer projects could beryllium connected to its underground rocket programme.
The study cited researchers who observed geographical similarities betwixt the locations of dams and sites targeted by US and Israeli aerial strikes.
According to the report, immoderate of the h2o and subject experts the NYT spoke to concluded that the “water projects whitethorn person been developed to enactment the country’s subject buildup”.
However, the paper itself acknowledged, “Given the secrecy surrounding Iran’s rocket program, immoderate transportation betwixt it and Iran’s ambitious, decades-old inaugural to make h2o infrastructure remains speculative. But immoderate experts find the grounds highly suggestive.”
Why is the study causing a backlash?
Critics fearfulness that portraying dams arsenic perchance serving subject purposes could supply a justification for attacking infrastructure indispensable to millions of civilians.
US-Israeli attacks connected Iran since February 28 person damaged lipid facilities, powerfulness plants, h2o reservoirs, bridges, hospitals and different civilian infrastructure.
US President Donald Trump has repeatedly threatened further attacks, saying past week that cardinal Iranian infrastructure could beryllium destroyed wrong 3 days.
Political expert Rami Khouri called the NYT study “troubling”, saying it reaffirmed his concerns astir US mainstream media being “complicit successful the US-Israeli transgression attacks connected Iran, conscionable arsenic it was during the warfare connected Iraq decades agone and the ongoing genocide successful Gaza”.
“The telltale motion of non-credible wobbly journalism is erstwhile conditional words similar ‘speculative’, ‘suggestive’, ‘may person developed’, ‘may shed light’, ‘suspect’, and ‘long-term riddle’ hap much often than immoderate definitive, evidence-based facts.”
Khouri said it was “not definitive and verified reporting” and “another effort to enactment the US-Israeli urgency to find immoderate crushed to transportation retired much warfare crimes against Iran” by attacking captious infrastructure.
“Another bittersweet time for US mainstream journalism,” helium added.
Why is the communicative falling apart?
Aside from online disapproval from readers and commentators, experts cited successful the communicative person themselves travel retired against aspects of the report.
Kaveh Madani, manager of the United Nations University’s h2o institute and a erstwhile elder Iranian biology official, 1 of the experts cited successful the story, challenged the report’s reasoning.
“Speculation is not evidence. Spatial proximity is not causality,” helium wrote connected X.
“Even those who attacked Iran person not made specified claims linking dams to missiles! This reductionist, sensational communicative is irresponsible journalism with perchance unsafe consequences for civilian h2o infrastructure. The New York Times should cognize better.”
Madani besides questioned the newspaper’s assertion that 7 experts had supported its analysis. “I’m 1 of the radical quoted successful the article, but my comments had thing to bash with dams oregon missiles!” helium added.
Nima Shokri, a water-security adept astatine Hamburg University of Technology, whose probe featured prominently successful the investigation, besides issued a clarification.
“The proximity of dams to subject targets does not found wherefore those dams were built, nor does it warrant attacks connected them,” helium said connected X.
A 3rd researcher quoted successful the nonfiction echoed Shokri’s comments.
“I afloat hold [with Shokri],” Amir Aghakouchak, a h2o adept astatine the University of California, Irvine, wrote connected X, sharing Shokri’s X post.
“Dams and h2o infrastructure are indispensable to civilian beingness and indispensable ne'er go targets of subject attacks. Regardless of their determination oregon imaginable strategical significance, their superior roles successful h2o supply, nutrient security, energy, and biology sustainability indispensable not beryllium overlooked. Protecting these captious resources should beryllium a priority, careless of authorities oregon conflict.”
The paper rejected accusations that its probe could supply a pretext for subject attacks.
“Our study connected Iranian dams accurately cited probe and investigation by 7 planetary experts connected Iran’s situation and subject presence,” spokesperson Nicole Taylor said.
She added that the NYT’s journalists had sought to explicate Iran’s infrastructure concern and the effects of US and Israeli attacks connected civilians.
“Framing the autarkic reporting arsenic a pretext for unit is dangerous,” Taylor said.
One of the story’s co-authors, Sanam Mahoozi, said that “neither I nor our study endorses oregon justifies attacks connected dams oregon different infrastructure”.
“As a journalist, I invited rigorous, constructive criticism, but I anticipation immoderate users volition critique the study fairly, based connected what was really written,” she posted connected X. The communicative was co-written with Erika Solomon, the NYT bureau main for Iraq and Iran.
What has Iran said?
Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi dismissed the allegations arsenic “rubbish”, accusing what helium suggested was pro-Israel media of promoting narratives reminiscent of the run-up to the 2003 US penetration of Iraq.
“Spare america the Iraq War-style propaganda, particularly with Israeli fingerprints each implicit it,” helium wrote connected X.
Iran’s parliament talker and main negotiator, Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, accused the paper of preparing the crushed for further attacks connected civilian infrastructure.
“New rule: Any dam, port, oregon powerfulness works adjacent a US oregon Israeli basal is dual-use. We’ll use your logic consistently and even-handedly,” helium posted connected X.
Why are radical questioning the NYT’s credibility?
The contention has revived wide disapproval of the newspaper’s reporting earlier the US-led penetration of Iraq, erstwhile claims astir Saddam Hussein’s alleged weapons of wide demolition helped physique nationalist enactment for war.
Judith Miller, a erstwhile NYT journalist, was among the reporters whose sum amplified claims astir Iraq’s weapons programmes that subsequently proved unfounded.
In September 2002, Miller co-authored a study claiming Iraq had intensified its pursuit of atomic weapons, citing US officials who alleged that Baghdad was seeking aluminium tubes for uranium enrichment.
Former Vice President Dick Cheney cited the newspaper’s reporting connected aluminium tubes to bolster President George W Bush’s administration’s lawsuit against Iraq. The claims were aboriginal discredited.
Two months aft the penetration of Iraq began successful March 2003, Miller co-authored a study citing that US quality agencies had concluded that 2 mysterious trailers recovered successful Iraq were mobile units to “produce germs for weapons”.
However, a twelvemonth aft the US warfare connected Iraq began, the NYT acknowledged superior shortcomings successful its reporting connected the build-up to war, including its reliance connected Iraqi defectors and exiles seeking authorities change.
“We person recovered a fig of instances of sum that was not arsenic rigorous arsenic it should person been,” it said.
.png)
4 days ago
20

















Bengali (BD) ·
English (US) ·