WARMINGTON: Transparency needed after teen accused of GTA synagogue shootings

Justice system seems to be prioritizing the rights of the accused, now 18, over giving the public vital information

Get the latest from Joe Warmington straight to your inbox

Published May 06, 2026  •  3 minute read

Israel’s Ambassador to Canada Iddo Moed looks at bullet holes fired at the Beth Avraham Yoseph of Toronto Synagogue in Vaughan, Ont., on Thursday, March 12, 2026. Photo by Peter J Thompson /Postmedia Network

The priority of the Canadian justice system is not to tell the public the name of the teen accused of shooting up two GTA synagogues, which has terrified the Jewish community.

The priority is to keep that information from the public because the 18-year-old they arrested was just 17 last month when the incidents happened, so the teen who allegedly fired the shots is now calling the shots.

Article content

Article content

In Canada, some things are more important than full transparency. If you look closely at the charge sheet for the accused, you would never know these violent incidents were suspected antisemitic attacks.

A Toronto Police news release said an unnamed individual was charged with unauthorized possession of a firearm in a motor vehicle, unauthorized possession of a firearm, possession of a prohibited device, careless storage of a prohibited device, occupying a motor vehicle with a prohibited device and two counts each of discharging a firearm into a place and mischief to property over $5,000.

Article content

‘Suspected hate-motivated crimes’

However, these were not firearm discharges into just any buildings, these were synagogues in Toronto and York Region that were shot up. Toronto Police and York Regional Police have made that clear in their releases these were places of worship and while there is nothing in either news release indicating these are being probed as potential hate or terror crimes, both indicate they are both still under investigation.

Toronto Police spokesperson Const. Ashley Visser, however, assured the Toronto Sun that “these offences are being investigated as suspected hate-motivated crimes.”

This is a positive. It’s appreciated to see police not playing that woke and watered-down game.

But there is so much we don’t know. For example, because the 18-year-old accused was 17 at the time of the March shootings, his name and photograph are protected under the Youth Criminal Justice Act.

It has been said the teen made a court appearance Wednesday and is expected back for a second appearance on May 20, but it’s not clear if he will remain in custody until then. Another thing we know is this was good police work to nab him. But since the YCJA nonsense kicks in, it now becomes a game of secrecy by keeping from the public basic information that could help shine a light on who he is and what affiliations he may have?

Article content

Article content

Daniel Stopnicki. Photo by Toronto Police

So many unanswered questions

Thanks to the system, information is not as accessible as one may like it to be. For example, we know police charged an adult male for allegedly shooting up two synagogues, but we don’t know the identity of the accused. We know police have in custody a 67-year-old former Ontario cop and head of security at York University, Michaelo Markicevic, who is accused of the murder of Jewish man Daniel Stopnicki.

But we don’t know why Stopnicki, 47, was shot to death in a city park.

What we do know is there is a lot more to know about violent attacks on Jewish places of worship and on a Jewish citizen who from all accounts so far did not know his attacker and was merely walking his pet Chihuahua in Wenderly Park a week ago when met with his execution.

Michaelo Markicevic, 67, of Toronto, has been charged with second-degree murder. Photo by TORONTO POLICE

But one thing the Jewish community was in agreement on Wednesday was its appreciation that police are working so hard on these cases.

“We appreciate the seriousness with which the authorities have treated this matter thus far,” B’nai Brith Canada director of research and advocacy Richard Robertson said. “The impact of the shootings on the Jewish community cannot be understated. The community has been left paralyzed for two months while the authorities worked to apprehend the suspect.”

Article content

Councillor James Pasternak surveys a Dufferin St. and Steeles Ave. business in his ward that was shot up.

Community ‘greatly relieved’ by arrests

Toronto Councillor James Pasternak agreed: “We are greatly relieved and thankful that an arrest has been made in the disgraceful shootings of synagogues in Vaughan and Toronto (and) are hopeful that this arrest will lead to a treasure trove of information that can identify any source of funding for these crimes, any accomplices or other groups involved.”

The important thing is the justice system’s concern about protecting a teenager should not outweigh the gravity of these serious allegations.

That it does should not be tolerable.

“As the investigation continues, it is paramount that consideration be given to whether the crime was hate motivated or an act of terrorism,” said Robertson.

It’s so true. These are not routine crimes.

Read More

1. 

   WARMINGTON: While it may have looked like an armed terrorist, it was just a man doing cosplay

2. 

   WARMINGTON: Head-in-sand approach to antisemitism will come back to bite Toronto

Article content