Vaughn Palmer: B.C. premier pivots on reason for snap election

B.C. NDP Leader David Eby speaks during the B.C. election provincial leaders' debate in Vancouver on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. Photo by Ethan Cairns /B.C. Broadcast Consortium

Article content

VICTORIA — Premier David Eby drew the first question of this week’s leaders’ debate, and was asked the rationale for what is proving to be the most controversial decision of his political career.

Article content

“Nearly two-thirds of British Columbians say it is too soon for another election,” began moderator Shachi Kurl of the Angus Reid Institute. “How can anyone believe this snap election is anything less than an opportunistic power grab?”

Article content

Article content

Article content

On the day he called the election, Eby had overwhelmingly justified it as necessary to defend B.C. against the tariffs and attacks of U.S. President Donald Trump.

Article content

Article content

That argument failed to persuade the electorate. So he has now pivoted, saying the primary reason was to rectify the NDP’s too-meagre seat count in the legislature.

Article content

“When you have a one-seat majority, every vote could bring down the government,” argued Eby. “This was not a government that was able to deliver the big swings that you and your family need the government to be taking for you.”

Article content

Alas, for the math-challenged NDP leader, when he called the election he had a three-seat majority in the provincial legislature. Moreover, to then create a four-seat gap over the combined opposition, he needed only to call a byelection in vacant Vancouver-Strathcona, the safest NDP seat in the province.

Article content

Eby’s second rationale for the snap election call was no more persuasive or less desperate than the first.

Article content

Still, it was breathtaking to contemplate the sudden disappearance of the hated Trump.

Article content

During a Sept. 22 news conference where the NDP leader announced the election, he made 20 separate references to Trump by name.

Article content

Article content

In the leaders’ debate Wednesday, Eby named Trump just once, when he heckled Conservative leader Lorne Doerkson for failing to acknowledge the impact of the latest tariffs on softwood lumber.

Article content

From 20 references to one. Now that is what I call a pivot.

Article content

Eby faced a follow-up question about a related controversy with his early election call.

Article content

“Local politicians implored you not to do this. You went ahead anyway. Candidates are now reporting widespread voter confusion. Why should voters see this as effective leadership instead of a failure to listen?”

Article content

True to form, Eby ignored the question and instead repeated the need to improve his supposed one-seat majority.

Article content

However, on the eve of the leaders’ debate, Doerkson promised a change to ensure no repeat of Eby’s overlap.

Article content

“David Eby scheduled some advance voting days at the exact same time as municipal voting day. That was not an accident. It was a calculation, and an irresponsible and selfish one,” said Doerkson by news release.

Article content

“If British Columbians choose to make me their next premier, one of our first acts will be to pass a law to make sure this never happens again. Voters need space to hear from the people who want to represent them. Candidates need a fair chance to be heard.”