The Good Daughter is the latest attempt by Peacock to get in on the prestige thriller subgenre and make more of a name for itself in the streaming world. Based on the book by Karin Slaughter, who also serves as showrunner and wrote all six episodes, the series aims to hook audiences with its central mystery and keep them invested by exploring the relationship between the two sisters serving as our lead characters. Ironically enough, the latter ends up being a far better selling point than the former.
While The Good Daughter is not a bad show by any means, the actual meat of the story never lives up to the tantalizing framing of its big questions. By contrast, the leads in particular deliver emotionally resonant and downright spectacular work that is arguably better than the project really deserves.
What is The Good Daughter about?
Photo by: Mark Hill/PEACOCKOur story begins twenty years after the lives of sisters Charlie and Sam, played by Meghann Fahy and Rose Byrne, respectively. were irrevocably altered by a single night of horrific violence. Now, the two must reunite to investigate another horrific attack in their small hometown of Pikeville, Georgia. A task made more complicated by Charlie, now a defense lawyer like her father Rusty, played by Brendan Gleeson, being the first witness to the attack. Together, the sisters must unravel the surprising connections between the past and present and how their bond can bring them back from the brink.
The Good Daughter Review
Photo by: Mark Hill/PEACOCKThe biggest problem with The Good Daughter is that it desperately wants its A and B stories to feel more connected than they are. While both the past and present plotlines are obviously incited by violent attacks, they happen in very different contexts with very different consequences and are each ultimately suited to very different thematic explorations. But the show doesn’t feel especially interested in exploring these individual stories on their own, only how they can connect. Thus, as the mysteries go on, they become more written in service of facilitating those connections rather than what makes the most sense for them as stories.
As a result, the big reveals meant to keep the audience invested are either painfully generic or completely out of nowhere, all in service of connecting the two stories as much as possible, regardless of whether or not they should be connected. Moreover, the pacing feels consistently off here. With only six episodes to tell the whole story, by the time a particular plot or character finds its footing, we have to jump right into the next one and start the process over again. And when things finally start to feel fully established and moving, we’re already at the climax.
Photo by: PeacockThese issues are only further exacerbated by the fact that all of our various antagonists are the most generic small-town Southern bigots I’ve seen in a mainstream work in ages. Is that accurate to real life? Generally, yes. Is it compelling to watch as entertainment or have anything meaningful to say about bigotry that hasn’t already been said by a million other, better artistic works? Unfortunately, no. Frankly, if I really wanted to listen to a bunch of white men prattle on about how women are terrible, I’d watch the average guest speaker on Fox News.
Thankfully, The Good Daughter does manage to nail one key aspect, and that is its protagonists and supporting cast. It’s always fun to see Harper Steele pop up as the dry-witted coworker Lenore, Brendan Gleeson as Charlie and Sam’s father is both delightful and even profound in places; and Meghann Fahy and Rose Byrne absolutely nail it as our central sisters. Their confidence, chemistry, and emotional authenticity are downright electric to watch and keep the story compelling even when the writing is at its lowest.
Is The Good Daughter worth watching?
Photo by: Daniel McFadden/PEACOCKWhile The Good Daughter isn’t necessarily anything to write home about, you could certainly do a lot worse. Despite the mystery story’s issues and the boring villains, our main leads work incredibly well, it’s technically well put together, and when the emotional moments hit, they very much hit. It’s far from perfect, but if you’ve got the free time and are desperate for something new, it could very well be worth a binge.
The Good Daughter premieres November 12 on Peacock. All six episodes reviewed.
The Good Daughter Review: Brilliant Performances Elevate Lackluster Drama
The Good Daughter's central mysteries are either too easy to guess or utterly ridiculous, but Meghann Fahy, Rose Byrne, and Brendan Gleeson's powerhouse performances keep things entertaining.
.png)
1 week ago
7



















Bengali (BD) ·
English (US) ·