Sask. Metis group leaves national council over Ontario members it says are non-Metis

The Saskatchewan group says the Metis Nation of Ontario, which is a member of the national body, accepts and continues to represent people who are not Metis

Author of the article:

The Canadian Press

Alessia Passafiume

Published Sep 19, 2024  •  5 minute read

Glen McCallum, president of the Métis Nation of Saskatchewan, speaks during a press conference in Regina on June 24, 2024. Photo by Heywood Yu /The Canadian Press

OTTAWA — The Metis Nation of Saskatchewan has pulled out of a national body representing Metis, citing problems with an Ontario group and throwing the future of the Metis National Council into question.

In a resolution passed Thursday morning, the Saskatchewan group says the Metis Nation of Ontario, which is a member of the national body, accepts and continues to represent people who are not Metis.

Article content

“The Metis National Council has increasingly been used for advocacy purposes that are inconsistent with its original mandate and vision, diverting from the foundational role of representing Metis rights and self-determination,” the resolution says.

It also says the Metis National Council has failed to ensure the integrity of the Ontario group’s citizenship registry and has not rectified problems, despite constant calls to do so.

The resolution says its continued association with the Metis Nation of Ontario “no longer benefits the Metis Nation within Saskatchewan or the Metis Nation as a whole.”

The Metis Nation of Ontario did not immediately respond to a request for comment, but has previously defended its citizenship registry as being legitimate.

The departure of the Saskatchewan group comes years after the Manitoba Metis Federation withdrew from the council, citing similar concerns about the Metis Nation of Ontario.

“This was not a decision our government made lightly but one we felt necessary. Our (Metis Nation of Saskatchewan) government and our Metis communities need to have control over our identity and culture while making decisions that align with the values of our Saskatchewan Metis Nation,” said president Glen McCallum in a statement on Thursday.

Article content

The Metis National Council was, until Thursday, comprised of the Metis Nation of Saskatchewan, the Metis Nation of Alberta, the Metis Nation of Ontario and the Metis Nation of British Columbia.

Recommended from Editorial

1. 

   Indigenous summit condemns groups it says are co-opting First Nation identities

2. 

   'Pretendian' the ultimate step in colonialism, says Metis legal expert

The Saskatchewan group was a founding member along with the Alberta group and the Manitoba Metis Federation.

According to the national council’s bylaws, quorum for its board of governors meetings must include two of the founding members. As of now only one remains, bringing into question the future of the organization, which often works with the federal government and advocates internationally for Metis.

Will Goodon, who serves as the Manitoba Metis Federation’s housing minister, said the national body is “dead today,” as it cannot call for a board of governors meeting or an assembly with only one founding member.

Asked whether the departure could lead to the creation of a new advocacy body, Goodon said he’s sure there will be conversations. “Maybe not out in the open right away, but you just never know.”

Article content

He said he’s excited that other Metis groups are calling attention to the Metis Nation of Ontario, noting the Manitoba Metis Federation raised concerns to the federal government in 2017.

“Perhaps the crisis was a good thing so that we could move the needle on how Canadians view the historic Metis Nation — there’s a better understanding today than there was five years ago, that’s for certain,” he said.

The Metis National Council, meanwhile, said its work is not yet done, while recognizing the Saskatchewan group has the right to self-determination.

“The (Metis National Council) is committed to continuing the work to advance the aspirations of our ancestors, building a prosperous future for now and for the next generation of Metis,” the council said in a statement.

Metis National Council president Cassidy Caron announced earlier this year she would not be seeking re-election, leaving an open contest for someone to fill her post.

The board voted to postpone and reschedule a September vote and general assembly to November. Caron said in a newsletter that her term will end on Sept. 30 either way.

Article content

“With these recent developments, President Caron will be meeting with (Metis National Council’s) governing members to discuss next steps,” the council said Thursday. “We will share more information as it arises.”

The Saskatchewan group had already pulled support for federal legislation that would enshrine its self-government over concerns about the Metis Nation of Ontario and the Metis Nation of Alberta, which was also included.

McCallum said in April the legislation was holding the group back, and it needed to put the needs of Metis in Saskatchewan first.

First Nations chiefs in Ontario and the Manitoba Metis Federation consistently raised concerns about the Ontario group as the legislation was being studied by a House of Commons committee, with Metis Nation of Ontario president Margaret Froh billing the self-government process as the longest in Canadian history.

First Nations chiefs in Ontario have accused the federal government of overstepping its jurisdiction and alleged the legislation infringes on their rights.

The Assembly of First Nations, which represents some 630 chiefs across Canada, passed a resolution calling for the federal government to kill the legislation altogether. The AFN’s concerns are mainly focused on six new communities the Metis Nation of Ontario and the province recognized in 2017, which it says have no historical basis to exist.

Article content

The Manitoba Metis Federation has also opposed the extension of self-government to the Metis Nation of Ontario, saying the Ontario group’s membership is not on par with its definition of Metis.

The Metis Nation of Ontario has disputed that, pushing back against the idea Metis only exist around the Red River in Manitoba.

In a statement, Ontario regional Chief Abram Benedict said he knows the Metis Nation of Saskatchewan’s decision was not made lightly, saying the Ontario organization’s “claims have not stood up to scrutiny and we’re now seeing the repercussions.”

“We’ve been at this for a long time, and we’ve read all the research. It’s encouraging to see that others are taking notice of what First Nations in Ontario and legitimate Metis Nations have been saying for years,” he said.

“The (Metis Nation of Ontario) is a group that’s been getting away with making unfounded claims in First Nations ancestral and treaty territories in Ontario for far too long.”

Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here.

Article content