Raptors blown out in Cleveland in ugly return to playoffs

Spectacular Donovan Mitchell game, James Harden's precision too much as Toronto got taken out of its game.

Get the latest from Ryan Wolstat straight to your inbox

Published Apr 18, 2026  •  Last updated 1 hour ago  •  4 minute read

Evan Mobley #4 of the Cleveland Cavaliers dunks over Collin Murray-Boyles #12 and Scottie Barnes #4 of the Toronto Raptors during the second quarter of Game One of the Eastern Conference First Round NBA Playoffs at Rocket Arena on April 18, 2026 in Cleveland, Ohio. Photo by Jason Miller /Getty Images

Toronto’s long-awaited return to the NBA playoffs started out decently enough Saturday before careening off the rails in Cleveland.

Article content

In the post-season for the first time in four years, the Raptors stuck close to the Cavaliers in the first and second quarters despite not playing their favoured brand of fast-break basketball, before the roof caved in not long into the second half. Cleveland went ahead by 22 points, scored nearly 100 in three quarters alone and easily won Game 1, 126-113.

Article content

Article content

Donovan Mitchell, who made first-team All-NBA last season, was spectacular, scoring 32 points. Former MVP James Harden was steady, adding 22 plus 10 assists. Young Evan Mobley was solid with 17 and reserve Max Strus lit up the Raptors for 24 points.

RJ Barrett led Toronto with 24 but had a rough night defensively, Scottie Barnes had 21, and Brandon Ingram and Jamal Shead with 17 each.

Facing a lot more pressure than the green Raptors, the Cavaliers drew first blood in this fourth vs. fifth seed series. And if things continue this way, there might not be a return trip to Cleveland later this month.

Some takeaways from a deflating Raptors performance and the team’s first loss against Cleveland this season:

Article content

Article content

NOT WHAT YOU WANT

Toronto led the NBA in fast-break points and thrived getting out in the open court. The plan was to force Cleveland into mistakes and convert at the other end. Instead, a Cavaliers team that yearns to play at its own speed — slowly, methodically, picking opponents apart — did just that. For three quarters, transition basketball was simply not a thing. Neither side managed a single point on the fast-break in the first quarter. They managed one, combined, in the second and totalled just three after three quarters.

The only reason Toronto even stuck within about 20 points was because the team shot extremely well on three-point attempts (especially since Cleveland hit even more threes on a similar high percentage).

Toronto did outscore Cleveland on the break in the end — but it was only 3-2, not nearly enough.

WEIRD BARNES GAME

This was a strange game for top Raptor Scottie Barnes. He started out extremely aggressively, trying to attack inside and even got called for a rare offensive foul when he attempted to push a defender away on the way to the rim. Barnes was dared to shoot and hit three three-pointers in the first quarter, a number he’s never previously reached in any one quarter, per ESPN.

Article content

Two early fouls took him out of the game, although he briefly re-entered late in the first. He didn’t look the same in the second or third quarters, shooting just 1-for-8 from the field, including an uncommon 1-for-4 in the paint.

Barnes then looked completely different again in the fourth, attacking the Cavaliers relentlessly to great effect.

Whether it was Toronto going smaller (both Jakob Poeltl and Collin Murray-Boyles were off the floor when Barnes went off) or something was off, he didn’t let the Raptors go gently despite the big deficit.

Ingram only took one shot in the second half of the game, leaving Barnes and Barrett, who started terribly but ended up leading the team in scoring, to do most of the offensive work.

SHEAD STEPS UP

With Immanuel Quickley unable to play due to his hamstring injury, Raptors head coach Darko Rajakovic had two options: He’s often gone with Ja’Kobe Walter starting in place of Quickley, keeping Jamal Shead on the bench and shifting Barnes to more of a point forward role. But he decided to start Shead in this one and the sophomore rewarded him with a career outside shooting night. Shead nailed five three-pointers (on his first six attempts) for the first time in his career (he’d only once even hit four).

Article content

Shead acted as an outlet instead of a creator and he bailed the Raptors out several times.

Defensively, he struggled not to foul and to contain Cleveland’s two superstars. Shead had previously this season guarded Mitchell better than just about anyone.

BENCH GOES QUIET

Toronto’s reserves got their first taste of playoff basketball (other than Sandro Mamukelashvili watching as an inactive player on Milwaukee as a rookie) and didn’t look super comfortable. Other than Murray-Boyles, who only missed one of his six shot attempts, grabbed some rebounds and handed out four assists, nobody had it going offensively. Walter, the best story of Toronto’s second half of the season, had no impact, nor did Mamukelashvili, arguably one of the five most impactful reserves this season coming in.

Shead of course did, but had to as part of the starting lineup since Quickley did not play.

They’ll need more from the bench moving forward.

AROUND THE RIM

Toronto fell to 1-9 on the road in playoff series openers and 5-18 overall in openers, but much of that is impacted by the 1-12 record in the franchise’s first 13 playoff Game 1s. Cleveland snapped a two-game home Game 1 losing streak and is now 13-2 against the Raptors in playoff games … Barrett and A.J. Lawson became the fifth and sixth Canadians to play in the postseason for the Raptors. Cory Joseph, Chris Boucher, Khem Birch and Dalano Banton did it previously … Cleveland outscored Toronto 52-36 in the paint.

@WolstatSun

Read More

1. 

   Raptors' Immanuel Quickley says injury 'unfortunate' but hopes to face Cavaliers in playoffs

2. 

   How an NBA ruling could cost Raptors’ Scottie Barnes his shot at major awards

3. 

   Why Raptors can't afford to be without Immanuel Quickley in playoffs
4. 

   Raptors rest up after avoiding play-in while fans get ready to rock Jurassic Park

Article content