Opinion: What next? Euphoria over U.S. midterms fades under trade policy reality checks 

5 days ago 9

Article content

Now, enter the Democrats and with them our hopes that they will bring saner heads to prevail. But can we count on them to return us to a CUSMA free-trade environment?

Article content

Historically, the Democrats have not been flag-carriers for free trade. Canada’s free-trade pacts with the U.S. have all been negotiated by Republican administrations. In January 2020, CUSMA was approved by the U.S. Senate by a vote of 89 to 10. Of the “nays,” eight were Democrats, including party heavyweights such as current Senate Minority leader Chuck Schumer, Senator Cory Booker and then-Senator, later vice-president and presidential nominee, Kamala Harris. With respect to B.C.’s largest trade battle with the U.S., it should be noted that the current 35 per cent tariff on softwood lumber exports was initiated under Democratic President Joe Biden. Trump added a 10 per cent top-up as an alleged “national security” measure.

Article content

A large part of Trump’s road to victory over the past few elections has been through swing states in the U.S. rust belt where the Republicans have taken labour voters away from the Democrats. The Democrats will be fighting to get those once-loyal voters back. There is little that these voters like more than a journey to the past aided by some good old America-first protectionism. Such measures should block imports without increasing prices — as Trump’s tariffs on Canadian aluminum have on beer cans.

Article content

Advertisement 3

Article content

Several of the new representatives are heading to Congress under the fledgling wing of the Democratic Socialist movement. While this cohort has yet to define a distinct political platform, I would bet that free trade with Canada and Mexico is not going to be a priority in its anti-globalization agenda.

Article content

While Congressional election results are dramatic and clear, the path for a Democratic-controlled Congress to revoke Trump’s tariffs is less so. These tariffs have all been invoked under presidential authorities to take emergency action without any recourse to Congress. Some of these tariffs have been struck down by courts as unwarranted extensions of these emergency powers. Throughout waves of tariffs, the current Democratic minority in Congress has meekly asserted that tariffs are taxes and that Congress alone has the authority to raise taxes. But to no avail. Now that the tables have turned in Congress, it is still unclear how the Democrats will unstick this issue. Drafting legislation to promote affordability by revoking Trump’s tariffs will surely run into the president’s veto stamp — soon to replace his signature Sharpie as his favourite desk ornament. Despite their big win, the Democrats are over a dozen seats short of the two-thirds super-majority required in both the House of Representatives and Senate to overturn a presidential veto. Alternatively, the parties may choose the great American tradition of “lawyering up” and taking tariffs to court. Both scenarios threaten paralysis.

Article content

Advertisement 4

Article content

So where does this leave Canada? Arguably, we gain leverage when American voters draw a direct line between Trump’s tariffs and cost-of-living affordability. But we’re not in control of how this manifests in action. What is clear though is that Canada cannot count on either Democrats or Republicans to return us to the tariff-free status quo that has prevailed in our bilateral trade over most of the past four decades. Borrowing Carney’s oft-quoted phrase, this is what a “rupture” in our relationship looks like.

Article content

It may be prudent to let the dust settle a bit and understand if and how the Democrats plan to act. Continuing to reinforce the connection between tariffs and affordability should be a strong focus. Equally, we should emphasize the impact of tariffs on the economies of U.S. states where Canada is the largest export market — as is now the case in over half of U.S. states, including five out of eight in which Democrats flipped Republican Senate seats in the midterms.

Article content

At best, we may hope that the emerging U.S. trade environment will be less chaotic — but it won’t be calm nor more certain. In light of this prospect, one wonders what could provide Canada a bigger incentive to turbo-charge our trade diversification initiatives.

Article content

Stuart Culbertson is a former deputy minister in the government of B.C. He served as B.C. Trade Representative during the Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement negotiations. He participated in the U.S. State Department’s International Leadership Visitor Program in 1995. 

Article content

Advertisement 2

*** Disclaimer: This Article is auto-aggregated by a Rss Api Program and has not been created or edited by Bdtype.

(Note: This is an unedited and auto-generated story from Syndicated News Rss Api. News.bdtype.com Staff may not have modified or edited the content body.

Please visit the Source Website that deserves the credit and responsibility for creating this content.)

Watch Live | Source Article