NP View: Alberta is already changing Canada

The Canadian flag and an Alberta provincial flag fly together in Cochrane. Photo by Gavin Young /Postmedia

Article content

Alberta is claiming its place in Confederation. When polls open on Monday, we encourage Albertans to vote to remain in Canada, and reject the second option to begin pursuing a separation referendum. Alberta’s challenges within the country are very real, but ultimately solvable — even if they involve some compromise, as is always the case in a democracy.

Article content

A strategy of changing the country from within is already working. The Impact Assessment Act was again found unconstitutional last Friday by the Alberta Court of Appeal, part of a successful effort by Premier Danielle Smith’s government to challenge Ottawa whenever it steps out of its constitutional lane.

Article content

Article content

Article content

Smith also deserves credit for bringing Prime Minister Mark Carney closer to her view on the resource sector, even though we are still hesitant to celebrate a pipeline.

Article content

Article content

There is much more that should be done, but the prime minister has jettisoned, or watered down, or created workarounds for, several destructive policies brought in under his predecessor. We believe Carney should go much further, but that Ottawa has come this far is a testament to what Alberta can achieve when it applies appropriate pressure.

Article content

There has even been some positive movement on judicial appointments, which we doubt would have happened without the Alberta government raising the quality of judges as a central issue. In June, Carney appointed to the Supreme Court Manitoba Justice Glenn Joyal, who has a long history of criticizing judicial overreach. Similarly, just this month, lawyer and academic Malcolm Lavoie, who is respected among those skeptical of judicial activism, was appointed to the Alberta Court of King’s Bench.

Article content

We hope to see more appointments like this and for Alberta to be more routinely heard.

Article content

Article content

It might be tempting to say that these successes were only possible because of the pressure provided by a looming referendum, and in one sense, it has been some time since Alberta has been this influential in national affairs. However, the province has successfully advanced its interests right from its inception. Alberta political leaders lobbied for provincehood, which was granted in 1905. Later, in the 1930s, and more directly in the 1980s, Alberta succeeded in gaining constitutional control over its resources.

Article content

Article content

The Smith government’s approach today is a continuation of that legacy. It also helps that Mark Carney’s support is drawn in part from moderates, even some conservatives, who want a clean break from the Justin Trudeau years. And despite the prime minister’s penchant for big government solutions, he seems to recognize that Canada’s resource sector is a key part of absorbing any trade damage inflicted by the United States.

Article content

Whatever role the possibility of a referendum has played, what matters is a government in Edmonton successfully making its case to Ottawa, building relationships with other provinces, and going to court whenever the federal government attempts to centralize a piece of provincial responsibility.