Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mom accused of killing her three children in 2023, is seeking to avoid a second murder trial after her first ended in a hung jury. In a recent development, her attorneys are asking the state’s highest court to overturn a ruling allowing a second trial, arguing the judge should have further investigated concerns about a juror before declaring a mistrial. Newly released jury notes also shed light on the deadlock.
Lindsay Clancy Defense Files Petition To Massachusetts’ Highest Court
Facebook | Lindsay ClancyOn November 16, Judge William Sullivan set Lindsay Clancy’s retrial date for March 29, 2027. Now, her defense attorneys are making another push to stop it, petitioning the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to reverse the judge’s decision.
In the appeal, Clancy’s attorneys said that their client “should not be ‘forced to run the gauntlet’ again.” Judge Sullivan declared a mistrial on September 4 after the jury deadlocked three times, with the final vote at 11-1 in favor of not guilty by reason of insanity.
Clancy’s team argues that Judge Sullivan should not have declared a mistrial and instead investigate the holdout juror. “There is a substantial possibility that the trial court, after inquiry, would have discharged the non-compliant juror,” the appeal read, adding that the judge could have removed the juror and replaced him with an alternate, per Boston.
The Jury’s Notes To The Judge Were Released
At one point during jury deliberations, Judge Sullivan individually questioned jury members about their ability to follow the law and judicial instructions. Afterward, they were ordered to continue discussions.
The mistrial was declared after about 38.5 hours of deliberations spread over seven days. Now, the notes written by the jury foreperson have been released, shedding light on their concerns.
One note read that a juror was “unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt” and asked the judge how to proceed.
In another, dated one day before the mistrial was declared, the foreperson said the holdout juror “has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states,” citing it as the reason they couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict.
What The Judge Said About The Holdout Juror
EXCLUSIVE: The lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy case is opening up to Fox News, revealing how some evidence shaped his thinking.
Michael Desronvil says he was struck by how "methodical" he believed Clancy was in the killings of her three young children.
After watching… pic.twitter.com/Ika3tu24dm
In previous hearings, Judge Sullivan addressed Clancy’s team’s argument about the holdout juror, saying the jury foreman’s notes did not show that the juror did not participate in deliberations or establish jury misconduct. Rather, he just disagreed with the rest of the members.
He further explained that the juror could not have been removed solely for reaching a different conclusion than the majority.
In addition, the judge said any investigation into the lone juror after the mistrial would have been “impermissibly coercive” and would discourage potential jurors from serving for fear of being investigated for disagreeing with the majority.
- Lindsay Clancy’s holdout juror said he saw a “mountain of evidence.”
- Her attorney asked the president for a pardon he can’t give.
- Patrick Clancy defended his ex-wife against harsh characterizations of her.
- Hearing Patrick’s “horrifying” 911 call affected one juror forever.
- A background investigation on the holdout juror sparked backlash.
Lindsay Clancy’s Charges Remain
Facebook | Lindsay ClancyClancy continues to face three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the deaths of her three children: 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson, and 8-month-old Callan.
While Clancy admitted to killing her children, she maintained that she was not in her right mind at the time, claiming she was suffering from postpartum psychosis. This formed the central argument of her defense during the first trial.
The prosecution has not made a public statement confirming Clancy’s charges for the retrial, but courtroom discussions in previous hearings strongly indicate they are maintaining the first-degree murder charges.
Lindsay Clancy’s Retrial Schedule
Facebook | Lindsay ClancyThe Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has taken Clancy’s petition under advisement, but has yet to issue a ruling.
As of now, the March 27, 2027, date for Clancy’s retrial remains unchanged, with a pretrial conference scheduled for February 18, 2027.
In the meantime, both the prosecution and defense are expected to return to court on December 30 for a status hearing, where they can address outstanding matters and provide updates as preparations for the retrial continue.
.png)
3 days ago
19

















Bengali (BD) ·
English (US) ·