‘Kids aren’t OK right now’: Conservatives join Liberals in asking whether social media should be banned for kids

Article content

“Your freedom or right to free speech isn’t being infringed upon because a minor can’t use social media,” he says.

Article content

Hogan added: “An algorithm does not have the rights to take up the bandwidth of an entire growing person’s brain.”

Article content

Others within caucus have echoed the fears being expressed by academics and those outside government around the policy, such as concerns around the effectiveness of such a ban, including in jurisdictions like Australia, which was the first in the world to legislate an outright prohibition for those younger than 16.

Article content

Article content

Anxieties have also emerged over privacy implications for methods used to verify a user’s age, from facial recognition software and government-issued digital identification. Then come the pitfalls around potentially cutting off children for whom social media acts as a vehicle for connection.

Article content

Finally, and most politically relevant, is whether Conservatives trust the Liberals to do it, after what the party has for years viewed as overreach under former prime minister Justin Trudeau, including in its last attempt to legislate against online harms which featured proposals to stiffen and expand existing hate-speech criminal provisions that civil society advocates broadly panned as draconian.

Article content

Article content

“An outright social media ban for youth may offer the Liberals a fresh angle with which to attempt to justify their speech restrictions, particularly now that they’ve orchestrated a majority government,” Conservative MP Michelle Rempel Garner warned as part of a lengthy Substack post on the matter.

Article content

Melissa Lantsman, one of the party’s deputy leaders, raised the Trudeau government’s freezing of bank accounts of supporters associated with the 2022 Freedom Convoy and its triggering of the Emergencies Act to quell the weeks-long demonstration.

Article content

On the idea of social media restrictions, Lantsman nevertheless pointed to a smattering of “ruby-red Republican states” that have their own measures in place, from Florida to Texas, writing on Substack that she some saw “some logic” in the government stepping in, similar to how it does for alcohol and cannabis.

Article content

“I think the conversation is ongoing in Ottawa, I think amongst all parties, and certainly in our party, of what that looks like in terms of protecting kids,” she told reporters.

Article content

Liberal MPs are still figuring out where to go, particularly after the party’s grassroots endorsed placing age restrictions on social media and AI chatbots at its recent policy convention, with Canadian Heritage Minister Marc Miller saying afterwards he was considering it “very seriously,” but not as a standalone policy.

Article content

Article content

“Part of my brain says this is a healthy thing, because these things are addictive,” said Ottawa MP Yasir Naqvi, who pointed out he was the father of a 10- and 14-year-old.

Article content

“On the other hand, I’m also mindful of the fact that when you ban things outright, there’s always a back doorway of getting access to it.”

Article content

Ben Carr, a Liberal MP and former high school teacher, says he hears a lot about online safety.

Article content

Conservative MP Michelle Rempel Garner: “An outright social media ban for youth may offer the Liberals a fresh angle with which to attempt to justify their speech restrictions.” Photo by Blair Gable/Postmedia/File

Article content

The Winnipeg MP also says he spoke with Miller about issues of jurisdictions in light of the recent announcement by Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew that his NDP government would move to ban social media and generative AI for minors — a move that has raised many questions about how the province would do it.

Article content

Miller, who is tasked with delivering for the government a new online safety bill, but one that is without a firm timeline, told reporters this week that “coordination” was needed and that the regulation of social media belonged in the federal government’s arena.

Article content

“Whether we’re talking about moratoriums, or the proper regulation of egregious online harms and that’s stuff that we’re frankly, a couple years behind in regulating, as we see other jurisdictions like Australia, like Britain, like France, taking action, so we need to take action as well,” he said.