Donna Kennedy-Glans: Alberta vote isn’t about rage-quitting Canada — it’s about renewing Confederation

Details from a 1885 photo of an 1884 painting by Robert Harris portraying the Fathers of Confederation meeting in Quebec in 1864 to settle the basics of a union of the British North American Provinces. (The original painting was destroyed in a 1916 Parliament Buildings fire.) Photo by Robert Harris / Library and Archives Canada

Article content

It’s impossible to know exactly what the original designers of Confederation envisioned when Alberta and Saskatchewan became provinces in 1905. But Clifford Sifton, Laurier’s Minister of the Interior, left a brutally clear blueprint:

Article content

“We desire, and all Canadian Patriots desire, that the great trade of the prairies shall go to enrich our people to the East, to build up our factories and our places of work, and in every legitimate way to our prosperity.”

Article content

Article content

Article content

Sifton’s formula worked — for a time. The Prairies fed Eastern industry, built the country, and kept the cheques flowing east. But that old Canada is broken. The machinery is grinding, trust has evaporated, and Alberta is tired of playing the reliable cash cow that gets kicked for producing milk.

Article content

Article content

Late last week, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith yanked the wheel: no binding separation referendum this October. Instead, Albertans get a clear either/or question on October 19: Should Alberta remain a province of Canada, or should the government begin the constitutional process toward one? Smith says she’ll campaign to stay — but she’ll respect the verdict.

Article content

Article content

For drama fans, the script writes itself: Canada: Designed to Fail. A creaking Westminster system in its death spiral. “Who Killed My Canada?” — starring B.C.’s David Eby dodging his own UNDRIP bullet, Prime Minister Mark Carney as the wise elder, and Danielle Smith as Captain Canada gently removing the knife from Ottawa’s throat.

Article content

Article content

Humour helps. So does honesty. Can we at least agree on the real questions? Is it possible to create the conditions for our kids to do better than we did? Can we rebuild a genuine meritocracy? Do we have the nerve to redesign Confederation for the crises we face — and the asteroid coming our way?

Article content

Article content

Back to Sifton. In 2026, Alberta isn’t the junior partner anymore — it’s the new economic engine, more like Ontario in its heyday. It makes hard-headed business sense to pipe Alberta oil to U.S. Gulf Coast refineries and help fuel America’s energy superpower resurgence. Those old enough to remember the Chevrolet jingle — “See the U.S.A. in Your Chevrolet” — will recall a confident era when Ontario hitched its wagon to Detroit’s boom via the Auto Pact. Today, some in the chattering class (hello, Steve Paikin) casually muse about winding down the auto sector. Seriously?

Article content

It’s also smart business to look beyond our borders. Parochial grievances won’t cut it when CUSMA negotiations loom, when wars reshape energy markets, and when leaders like Trump, Modi, Xi, and Putin play raw pragmatism. Tech giants are frustrated with Canada; Elon Musk patched things up with Trump in Beijing. Grievances are luxuries the world no longer indulges.