‘Better deal’: What’s behind Trump’s rejection of Iran’s truce offer?

Donald Trump has rejected Iran’s latest connection to extremity the warfare and reopen the Strait of Hormuz arsenic experts accidental the United States president believes Washington has much to summation by waiting than by accepting Tehran’s presumption astatine this moment.

“I cull their proposal,” Trump told reporters connected Saturday, arguing that Iran wants an statement due to the fact that it is “losing truthful badly”.

Recommended Stories

• list 1 of 3Pezeshkian says Iran ‘no longer trusts talks with Washington’
• list 2 of 3Trump rejects Iran’s seven-day roadmap to extremity warfare and reopen Hormuz
• list 3 of 3Iraq seeks US exemption from prohibition connected Iranian flights

“They privation to marque a deal, and I deliberation that’s fine,” Trump said. “I’d similar to marque a woody too. But that woody would not beryllium acceptable.”

On Sunday, Iranian ⁠⁠Foreign ⁠⁠Minister Abbas Araghchi said Tehran had ⁠⁠seen the archetypal absorption from ‌‌Trump to its connection but had yet to person a effect done ⁠⁠mediators. In the latest diplomatic efforts, Qatar has played a relation successful mediating talks betwixt Iran and the US connected the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly gathering successful New York.

Iran’s seven-day connection included Washington lifting its naval blockade of Iranian ports, waiving sanctions connected Iranian lipid sales, releasing an estimated $12bn successful frozen Iranian assets and observing a wider determination ceasefire, including successful Lebanon and Yemen.

Iran would past reopen the Strait of Hormuz and statesman negotiations with Washington connected a last agreement.

The latest proposals are akin to the June memorandum of knowing (MoU) the 2 countries signed. But the MoU collapsed past period owed to differences connected the presumption of the deal, which resulted successful an escalation successful attacks, peculiarly successful and astir the Strait of Hormuz, which fundamentally remains nether Iranian blockade.

According to experts, Trump’s rejection suggested that portion some sides proceed to publically permission the doorway unfastened for diplomacy, they stay acold isolated implicit who should marque the archetypal concessions.

“Trump’s calculation looks reasonably straightforward. He believes the operation of the naval blockade and economical isolation is yet squeezing Iran hard capable that Tehran’s latest connection is grounds of weakness alternatively than an connection Washington needs to seize,” Andreas Krieg, subordinate prof astatine King’s College London, told Al Jazeera.

His nationalist statement that Iran is “losing badly” is important due to the fact that it suggests helium thinks clip is improving the US bargaining position, Krieg said.

(Al Jazeera)

Why does Trump deliberation helium tin wait?

A cardinal portion of Trump’s calculation appears to beryllium a content that the economical unit connected Iran has not yet tally its course.

The Trump medication has escalated economical unit connected Tehran, tightening its naval blockade portion imposing sanctions targeting Iranian lipid revenues and threatening secondary sanctions against countries doing concern with Tehran.

Last week, the US imposed aviation sanctions connected Iran, disrupting flights. This came weeks aft US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent announced an economic unit campaign against Iran, promising to people Tehran’s fiscal interests crossed the world.

Richard Weitz, a elder nonresident subordinate chap astatine the NATO Defence College, told Al Jazeera that the White House whitethorn judge it tin “wait a spot and get amended terms”.

There is besides interest successful Washington astir Iran’s projected sequencing, helium said.

Therefore, Weitz said Washington whitethorn beryllium calculating that “economic unit implicit clip volition induce the Iranian authorities to marque much concessions”.

“This is what occurred arguably a decennary ago, starring to the 2015 Iran atomic woody arsenic the Iranian authorities decided it [the US] needed to extremity the economical sanctions successful instrumentality for making concessions connected its atomic programme,” helium added.

It is, therefore, imaginable that “we could spot the aforesaid benignant of trade-off successful the coming months”.

Iran could marque Trump ‘pay’

However, waiting for a woody besides carries sizeable governmental hazard for the US president, experts said, due to the fact that his Republican Party could suffer November’s midterm elections.

A precocious August Reuters/Ipsos canvass suggested 63 percent of Americans opposed the US-Israel warfare connected Iran portion 31 percent supported it. Rising substance and proscription costs could besides provender into broader cost-of-living concerns earlier the elections.

The occupation for Trump is that clip does not lone summation unit connected Iran, Krieg said. “The gamble is that clip cuts some ways,” helium noted.

With the midterms approaching, Trump does not privation to look to assistance the blockade, waive lipid sanctions and merchandise Iranian assets simply to regain entree to a waterway that Iran itself disrupted, Krieg said.

“But each further week besides means elevated vigor prices, continued subject vulnerability and mounting unit connected Gulf partners.”

The indispensable closure of the Strait of Hormuz has disrupted lipid and state flows from the Gulf nations, which beryllium connected vigor exports to concern their budgets.

Mohamad Elmasry, a prof astatine the Doha Institute for Graduate Studies, told Al Jazeera that Iran’s connection could beryllium viewed arsenic “kind of throwing a bony to Trump” by offering a imaginable way towards little lipid and state prices earlier the vote.

However, Iran whitethorn determine “to marque Trump wage for declining the connection and the accrued economical unit the state is under”, helium told Al Jazeera.

“They whitethorn determine that this is the clip to escalate … conscionable arsenic the midterms are approaching.”

The Republican Party is not doing good successful the polls, and a fig of its candidates are “distancing themselves” from Trump, helium noted. Polls indicated that Republicans could suffer their slim majorities successful the US Congress.

It’s not conscionable the Iranians nether terrible economical unit due to the fact that of the US naval blockade and ongoing sanctions, “it’s besides the Trump administration,” Elmasry said.

Trump’s hold for much Iranian concessions could ‘backfire’

Trump “wants Tehran to reopen Hormuz without Washington paying the afloat economical and governmental terms Iran is presently demanding”, Krieg said.

“The information is that helium is confusing Iranian symptom with Iranian willingness to capitulate. Those are not the aforesaid thing.”

Iran is undoubtedly nether pressure. Krieg said the sanctions and blockade are “biting”, which is precisely wherefore Tehran needs an agreement.

But further unit does not needfully nutrient further concessions.

Iran could alternatively summation the costs of the struggle for its adversaries, Krieg said, including done the Strait of Hormuz, determination infrastructure and perchance Bab al-Mandeb, different strait betwixt Yemen and the Horn of Africa.

In caller weeks, the strategical value of Bab al-Mandeb has accrued dramatically aft the Iran-aligned Houthis expanded their power of Yemen’s Red Sea coastline.

This beforehand successful effect has handed the Houthis unrestricted access to the constrictive waterway, a worrying improvement for planetary shipping fixed the group’s way grounds of targeting vessels, including Israeli-linked ships, successful solidarity with Palestinians successful Gaza.

The Houthis person already declared a naval blockade connected Saudi ships successful the Red Sea, which Riyadh began to usage arsenic an alternate shipping way to Hormuz for its lipid exports.

“So this tin backfire,” Krieg warned. “Trump thinks Iran’s timepiece is moving faster than America’s. Tehran thinks the opposite: that Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the UAE, planetary vigor markets and yet Trump himself person a little tolerance for prolonged disruption than Iran has for economical punishment.”

Ross Harrison, a elder chap astatine the Middle East Institute, likewise told Al Jazeera that Tehran whitethorn present beryllium “less disquieted astir overplaying their manus than they are underplaying their hand”.

According to Harrison, Tehran present sees the hazard of escalation arsenic little costly than agreeing to thing prematurely oregon appearing consenting to compromise, peculiarly aft Washington’s effect to the proposal.

In an interview with Al Jazeera that aired connected Saturday, Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian said his state nary longer trusts negotiations with Washington aft attacks occurred during erstwhile rounds of talks and were followed by sanctions.

“We person nary spot successful the American broadside and bash not cognize connected what ground an knowing tin beryllium reached with it,” Pezeshkian said.

Tehran betting ‘heavily’ connected time

US-based expert Harrison noted that Tehran was astir apt “not amazed astatine all” by Trump’s rejection and viewed the connection partially arsenic a mode to show to Iranians and the American nationalist that it remained consenting to negotiate.

Experts said Tehran understands the US president wants an exit helium tin contiguous arsenic a victory.

“Iran is betting heavy connected time. … Its strategy is to support the unit precocious capable that helium yet comes backmost to negotiations portion making that exit progressively much expensive,” Krieg said.

“The Iranian calculation is essentially: Do not springiness Trump the woody cheaply erstwhile helium whitethorn request it much severely respective weeks oregon months from now.”

Harrison said the Iranian connection was a “show of goodwill” intended to show Iran’s willingness to negociate to some its home assemblage and the American public.

According to Krieg, “protraction” of the struggle was the “most apt outcome”.

“Both sides request a deal, but some presently deliberation waiting volition amended the woody they yet get,” helium added.