An organ donor saved her life. Now she’s marrying his brother.

"He was always cracking jokes, making me laugh," Brooklyn said. "He's just very sweet."

Author of the article:

Washington Post

Maggie Penman, The Washington Post

Published Sep 02, 2026  •  5 minute read

Noah Waters and Brooklyn Dotson on the night they got engaged in December 2025. Photo by Courtesy of Brooklyn Dotson /Courtesy of Brooklyn Dotson

See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source

Article content

Noah Waters was around 6 when he first met 3-year-old Brooklyn Dotson at her home in Kentucky. Her family invited his family over to say thank you for saving Brooklyn’s life.

Article content

Recommended Videos

Article content

Noah was so young that he didn’t really understand the situation, or how organ donation worked. He was still grieving his older brother’s death, and could never have imagined that decades later, the tiny girl who received his brother’s liver would one day become his wife.

Brooklyn, now 24, was born with a genetic condition that left her in need of a liver transplant when she was 1. She was on a hospital transplant list for months as the situation became increasingly dire.

“They gave Brooke three days to live without a transplant,” said her mom Ashley Baker, explaining her daughter was born with Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency.

Just after Christmas 2003, when she was 19 months old, a liver transplant came through. But her family’s miracle was the Waters family’s tragedy.

Michael Waters was 10 when he was hit by a car and died near his home in Dayton, Ohio. He was hearing impaired and playing at a friend’s house that day. His mom, Tina Poteet, thinks he didn’t hear the car coming when he stepped into the street.

Article content

Article content

Poteet said Michael was an unusually generous kid, often giving away his lunch to others who didn’t have enough to eat.

“It was kind of hard keeping up with everything Michael gave away,” Poteet said. “I can’t even tell you how many coats I bought for Michael.”

For years she thought Michael was losing them, but at his funeral she learned he had given his winter jackets away to kids who needed them.

Two years before he died, Michael had learned about organ donation and told his parents that if anything ever happened to him, he wanted them to donate his organs.

“It was Michael’s gift,” Poteet said. “That’s what made it easy that night at the hospital. We knew what he wanted.”

A few months after Michael died, Poteet reached out to Life Connection of Ohio to learn more about the people who had received his organs. It turned out that Baker was looking for her, too. The two mothers exchanged letters about their kids and made plans to meet. The story was first reported by local news station LEX18.

Article content

Michael Waters with his other little brother, Joseph. Photo by Courtesy of Tina Poteet /Courtesy of Tina Poteet

“Brooklyn might have been 2 or 3 when we first met her,” Poteet said. “She was so cute … So tiny and talking and bubbly.”

The two families stayed in touch, with Brooklyn and her mom making the five-hour drive to Ohio at least once a year. Noah and Brooklyn immediately became friends, and Brooklyn said Noah’s parents always treated her like part of their family, and her mom did the same for Noah.

“I kind of thought he loved her, way back when they were really young,” Poteet said of her son, who is now 27.

When Brooklyn was a freshman in high school she had a blockage in her liver and ended up back in Cincinnati Children’s Hospital for another surgery. Noah drove there from his home in Dayton as soon as he heard and sat by her bed for hours.

“He was always cracking jokes, making me laugh,” Brooklyn said. “He’s just very sweet.”

The two stayed in touch as Brooklyn started college at Lindsey Wilson University in Kentucky, where she studied counselling. Noah began a career as a project manager at a natural gas company in Ohio. They both dated other people, and Noah has an 8-year-old son from a previous relationship. Noah and Brooklyn became close friends, at times video-calling for eight hours in a day.

Article content

In the spring of 2025, Noah heard through family that Brooklyn had a crush on him.

“I was like, there’s no way,” Noah said. That weekend he drove from his home in Ohio to Kentucky to tell her he had always had feelings for her, too.

Perhaps because of their history, they said, it was almost immediately a serious relationship. She moved to Ohio to be with him in July last year. The two share five dogs and take care of Noah’s son part-time. Brooklyn said she loved seeing what a good dad Noah was.

Brooklyn Dotson and Noah Waters pose for a selfie. Photo by Courtesy of Brooklyn Dotson /Courtesy of Brooklyn Dotson

On Christmas Eve, he and Brooklyn went out to dinner in Columbus, Ohio, and he surprised her by asking her to marry him.

“I had planned a big elaborate thing, how I was going to do it and what I was going to say, and I couldn’t get it out,” Noah said. “I just told her I loved her and asked if she wanted to marry me.”

She said yes, and the two started planning their wedding, which will be later this month in a family friend’s backyard.

“It was supposed to be a small, intimate thing but it just grew and grew,” Brooklyn said. The couple is now expecting more than a hundred people. “I’m just very excited,” she said.

Article content

Brooklyn’s health has been good the past several years, and she still has regular check-ins with her doctors to make sure her liver is functioning well.

Noah said he was always close with his big brother, even though they were five years apart.

“He was a very protective big brother,” Noah said.

Noah was born with hearing impairments just like Michael, and when Noah was young, he had surgeries to improve his hearing. He said Michael would keep him company while he was recovering.

“He taught me how to ride a bike. All those things big brothers do,” Noah said.

Poteet still thinks about Michael every day, she said, adding: “There’s no happy spin that you could put on it.”

Noah said he hopes that sharing his family’s story will encourage others to consider organ donation. “You don’t know who you’re going to help,” he said.

Many of Michael’s organs were donated to help people, including his heart, kidneys and lungs. Poteet has kept in touch with some of the recipients, including one who will be a guest at the wedding – Freddy Perez, the man who received Michael’s heart.

“I feel incredibly blessed to have been given another opportunity to live years beyond what I would have without Michael’s courageous and selfless decision to become an organ donor,” Perez said.

Poteet said she’s grateful Michael was able to help so many others, including her future daughter-in-law.

“I think that the two just had magic and that they discovered that early on when they were tiny,” Poteet said of Brooklyn and Noah. “They were really pure little kids. They were just always really beautiful and loving together.”

Article content