Alberta independence referendum: Will separatists survive a loss?

Cory Morgan has spent much than 25 years warring for Canada’s oil-rich state of Alberta to go an autarkic country. On Monday, Albertans volition caput to the polls to ballot connected the contented for the precise archetypal time. But adjacent if the reply is no, Morgan said he’s successful it for the agelong haul.

“I would respect the volition of the voters,” helium told Al Jazeera. “If they’ve decided it’s not clip to spell that way yet, past truthful beryllium it. But that doesn’t mean I’ll stop.”

Recommended Stories

• list 1 of 4Canada to accelerated way lipid pipeline meant to diversify system distant from US
• list 2 of 4Secessionist enactment wins Quebec predetermination successful Canada
• list 3 of 4Canada’s Carney calls for unity arsenic Alberta prepares for secession vote
• list 4 of 4Fire astatine Canadian subject basal kills astatine slightest four, injures dozens

Morgan, the laminitis of the advocacy organisation Pathway to Independence, is among a radical of longtime separatists who person managed to propulsion what was erstwhile a fringe thought onto the ballot.

Monday’s provincial referendum asks Alberta residents to measurement whether they would similar to prosecute a binding solution successful the aboriginal connected the question of independence.

Polls bespeak the pro-independence broadside has small accidental of succeeding, with 4 of 5 radical successful the state saying they privation Alberta to stay a portion of Canada. But Morgan’s absorption is connected the 1 successful 5 who don’t.

“That’s not a question that’s leaving,” helium said.

What the referendum volition mean for the separatist question and for Canada arsenic a whole, however, is simply a much analyzable question.

What precisely are Albertans voting on?

Monday’s ballot gives Albertans 2 options: to stay portion of Canada oregon statesman the ineligible process for holding a aboriginal referendum connected separation.

A ballot successful favour of the 2nd enactment doesn’t mean Alberta instantly becomes an autarkic country.

Any state that tries to secede would archetypal person to spell done analyzable negotiations with the national authorities successful Ottawa, different provinces and Indigenous peoples who unrecorded successful and astir Alberta.

Some separatist organisers person been utilizing that favoritism to promote radical to ballot for the referendum — adjacent if they don’t needfully privation independence.

“Strategic separatists and their leaders person been utilizing that ambiguity, that lower-bar threshold, to entice folks to ballot not to leave, but alternatively to nonstop Ottawa a connection that Albertans request to beryllium heard,” said Jared Wesley, a governmental subject prof astatine the University of Alberta.

He told Al Jazeera that the connection whitethorn beryllium resonating with immoderate voters.

Data collected by Viewpoint Alberta, a University of Alberta-based probe initiative, suggests that two-thirds of voters who enactment the referendum accidental they’re doing truthful for strategical reasons, to nonstop a connection to Ottawa.

These are radical Morgan calls “reluctant separatists”, radical who are “at the extremity of their rope” and simply privation Ottawa to wage attention.

But Prime Minister Mark Carney has warned Albertans against this strategy.

“Don’t beryllium fooled by the thought you tin ‘send a message’ with your vote,” helium told a pro-Canada rally successful Calgary connected Thursday. “This is not poker. A ballot against Canada is simply a unsafe bluff that volition pb to years of heavy part and large uncertainty.”

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney speaks astatine a rally hosted by the advocacy radical Forever Canadian astatine the Edmonton Expo Center successful Edmonton, Alberta, connected Friday [AFP]

What’s driving Alberta’s separatist movement?

Monday’s referendum has been decades successful the making. Separatists person agelong felt that Alberta, location to the world’s fourth-largest proven lipid reserves, sends excessively overmuch wealth to Ottawa, subsidising the remainder of the state portion receiving small successful return.

They besides instrumentality contented with national vigor policies that they consciousness bounds the imaginable of the province’s lipid industry.

For Morgan, the resentment stretches backmost to the 1980s erstwhile the National Energy Program was introduced by the authorities of Pierre Trudeau, erstwhile Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s father.

The policy used terms controls, taxes and ownership rules to support Canadian vigor affordable portion directing much of Alberta’s revenues to Ottawa.

It has since go a cardinal awesome of “Western alienation”, a word utilized to picture the consciousness of disenfranchisement felt among Canada’s westernmost provinces.

Those tensions resurfaced decades aboriginal nether Justin Trudeau, whose word began successful 2015. His clime policies, including a nationalist c taxation and a bounds connected emissions, angered Alberta’s lipid sector.

“We’ve been warring astir the aforesaid things for 50 years,” said Morgan.

Then came the COVID-19 pandemic. Experts accidental demonstrations against wellness restrictions mobilised a caller procreation of blimpish activists, breathing caller beingness into Alberta’s separatist movement.

Trudeau yet resigned arsenic Liberal Party person and premier curate successful 2025, amid sinking canvass numbers. Carney was elected his replacement.

Last year, nether increasing unit from separatist groups, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s authorities made it easier to commencement referendums, helping bring the question of Alberta’s independency onto the governmental agenda.

For Wesley, the infinitesimal is little astir increasing nationalist enactment for independency and much astir unit from wrong Smith’s governing United Conservative Party, whose members amusement higher enactment for separation than Albertans generally.

“We’re having a referendum due to the fact that Danielle Smith wants america to person a referendum,” Wesley said. “She is looking to lick interior enactment matters by throwing a question to the broader public.”

Though she called Monday’s referendum, Smith has said she opposes the independency effort, and connected October 14, she announced she had voted against seceding.

“In my view, present is not the clip to springiness up anticipation successful our country, not erstwhile we person fought truthful agelong and travel truthful far,” Smith said successful a societal media video, explaining her vote.

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith speaks astatine the Canada Strong and Free league successful Calgary, Alberta, connected Friday [Ahmed Zakot/Reuters]

Could decision marque the question stronger?

Smith’s governmental gamble has drawn comparisons with the 2016 Brexit referendum successful the United Kingdom, including from Carney.

At the time, then-UK Prime Minister David Cameron called a ballot implicit whether the state should permission the European Union, successful hopes of settling a statement dividing his ain Conservative Party.

Voters yet chose to permission the bloc, triggering years of governmental unrest.

But Ian Cooper, a governmental idiosyncratic who grew up successful Alberta and present lives successful Ireland, says a much utile examination mightiness beryllium a antithetic UK referendum successful 1975, erstwhile British voters chose overwhelmingly to enactment successful what was past known arsenic the European Economic Community.

That vote, helium said, did small to deter those who wanted the state out.

“The activists who were successful favour of Brexit — this is earlier anybody called it Brexit — they truly played the agelong game,” helium said. “It took them 25 years, but they yet achieved it.”

Cooper suspects that, adjacent if Alberta separation is roundly defeated, separatists could instrumentality a akin approach, pursuing the contented implicit the agelong word to summation prominence and support.

“My content is that they truly are existent believers, and it’s truly ideologically driven,” helium said.

If Monday’s separatist ballot fails, Morgan said separatists would request to instrumentality a hard look astatine wherefore they had fallen abbreviated and enactment towards making a stronger lawsuit for independency successful the future.

He does not judge the underlying grievances tin beryllium resolved by moving wrong the Canadian strategy oregon by electing a much sympathetic national government.

Carney, who grew up successful Alberta, acknowledged astatine Thursday’s rally that “the frustrations that galore Albertans person felt are real”. He added that Ottawa had made radical successful the state consciousness “like our resources weren’t our own”.

The premier curate has tried, amid an ongoing commercialized warfare with the United States, to amended relations with Alberta, including done commitments to gathering a caller pipeline to Canada’s westbound seashore and large infrastructure projects.

Morgan admits that, for those whose extremity is simply to get much leverage successful Ottawa, “it’s beauteous wide the question has been effective”.

“We’ve seen much emotion from a national premier curate successful the past twelvemonth than we’ve seen successful the past 10,” Morgan said. “The occupation though, erstwhile it comes to stubborn independency folks similar me, is thing has changed successful the system.”

Prime ministers travel and go, helium added. “We’re conscionable 1 predetermination distant from different hostile one.”

Separatist organiser Cory Morgan speaks to Alberta separatist supporters astatine a gathering by Let’s Talk Alberta successful Calgary, Alberta, connected October 13, 2026 [Todd Korol/Reuters]

Why the different referendum questions matter

But the referendum could besides connection an accidental to situation the premise that Alberta’s grievances cannot beryllium addressed wrong Canada.

The independency question is conscionable 1 of 10 connected Monday’s ballot. Other proposals see restricting impermanent residents’ entree to healthcare and education, arsenic good arsenic allowing Alberta to take its ain judges.

Smith has encouraged Albertans to ballot successful favour of the 9 different proposals, arguing that they volition springiness her much negotiating powerfulness successful Ottawa.

“Many Albertans I talk with archer maine they privation to nonstop Ottawa a message, and I would suggest the champion mode to bash that is to springiness america a beardown mandate connected the different 9 questions,” she said connected societal media.

If Albertans backmost those proposals but Ottawa refuses to marque concessions, Cooper, the governmental scientist, said the question would person caller ammunition to reason that meaningful alteration wrong the existent strategy is impossible.

“Buried successful the 9 different questions are the seeds for a aboriginal referendum,” Cooper added.

What could support the question alive?

Not everyone agrees, however, connected whether the separatists tin look from the ballot arsenic a agreed force.

Wesley explained that radical person been drawn to the separatist origin for a assortment of reasons.

If there’s a consciousness that independency is not a realistic prospect, determination whitethorn beryllium small to support that radical of activists together, helium said. They could crook their attraction to different blimpish issues, specified arsenic immigration.

Other experts question whether Alberta’s separatist movement, which is agreed much by economical grievances than by a shared taste identity, tin endure the mode Quebec’s has.

Just 2 weeks ago, the mostly French-speaking state elected the separatist Party Quebecois, which has promised a 3rd referendum connected independency aft Trump leaves office.

Morgan, however, argues that Alberta does person a chiseled culture, shaped by generations of radical who person moved to the state successful hunt of prosperity.

“The benignant of idiosyncratic drawn to bash that is often an individualistic benignant of person,” helium said. “They privation the accidental to spell retired and win oregon neglect connected their own.”

“And that builds a benignant of a chiseled civilization connected its own, adjacent if it’s not a long-built one, arsenic you would spot successful a chiseled country similar Quebec with a linguistic quality oregon successful different country.”

Even if Albertans cull separation, helium believes the question has succeeded successful forcing Ottawa to instrumentality the province’s frustrations much seriously.

“Hopefully immoderate radical recognize that yet thing has to give,” helium said. “So immoderate the results are … I bash hope, astatine the precise least, they’ve served arsenic a wake-up telephone to a batch of people.”